Disputing the Charges

Emma emails David her supporting documents and calmly challenges the cleaning and repair charges. David explains his reasoning, while Emma asks for receipts and points out which items may count as normal wear and tear.

Dialogue10

Disputing the Charges
Emma
Emma

Hi, David. I’ve gone through the deduction list alongside my move-in checklist and move-out photos. I’d like to clarify two charges before we settle the deposit.

David
David

Of course. I charged for a professional cleaning because the kitchen and bathroom needed more attention, and for repairing the bedroom wall where I found several marks.

Emma
Emma

I understand why you wanted the apartment cleaned, but my photos show the oven and bathroom were in good condition. Could you send me the cleaning invoice and explain what needed extra work?

David
David

I can send the invoice. The cleaner said the refrigerator shelves and the oven still needed attention, although I admit I didn’t take detailed photos before the work was done.

Emma
Emma

Thanks. I’ve attached my dated move-out photos, and the move-in checklist already noted a small scuff on that wall. The other marks look like ordinary wear from living there.

David
David

I see the scuff on the checklist. The repair charge was for patching and repainting the wall, but I may have included more than the new marks actually required.

Emma
Emma

Would you be able to share the repair receipt or a breakdown of the work? I’m not disputing damage beyond normal wear, but I’d like the deduction to reflect only the documented repair.

David
David

That’s reasonable. I’ll send the receipt and ask the contractor to clarify which areas were repaired. If part of the work addressed the old scuff, I shouldn’t charge you for that.

Emma
Emma

I appreciate you checking. Once we’ve reviewed the invoice and repair details, could you revise the itemized statement and let me know when I can expect the remaining refund?

David
David

Yes. I’ll email both documents by tomorrow and update the statement after I’ve reviewed them. If the charges aren’t supported, I’ll remove or reduce them before sending the refund.

Vocabulary8

  • deduction list

    A list showing amounts taken off a payment or deposit. Here, it shows the charges David plans to subtract from Emma’s deposit.

  • move-in checklist

    A record of a property’s condition when someone moves in. It can help show whether damage was already there.

  • needed more attention

    Means something required extra cleaning or care. It is a tactful way to explain why more work may have been necessary.

  • ordinary wear

    Minor changes that happen through normal use over time. In this context, it helps distinguish everyday wear from damage a tenant may be charged for.

  • breakdown of the work

    A detailed explanation of the tasks completed, often with their costs. You can request one to understand how a repair charge was calculated.

  • itemized statement

    A document that lists each charge separately. It makes it easier to check whether each deduction is supported.

  • revise the itemized statement

    To update a list of charges, usually because some details have changed. This phrase is useful when asking someone to correct or reconsider a bill.

  • remove or reduce them

    To take charges off or lower their amounts. David uses this phrase to say he will adjust charges that are not supported by the documents.

Key Sentences8

  1. 1

    I’d like to clarify two charges before we settle the deposit.

    A calm, professional way to raise specific questions before an agreement is finalized. You can replace “two charges” with the items you want to discuss.

  2. 2

    Could you send me the cleaning invoice and explain what needed extra work?

    This combines a polite request for documentation with a request for an explanation. It is useful when you want to understand a charge without sounding confrontational.

  3. 3

    The other marks look like ordinary wear from living there.

    This sentence distinguishes minor changes from damage. “Look like” softens the claim, making it sound measured rather than absolute.

  4. 4

    I’m not disputing damage beyond normal wear, but I’d like the deduction to reflect only the documented repair.

    This acknowledges that some charges may be fair while clearly stating what evidence you expect. You can reuse the structure “I’m not disputing X, but I’d like Y” in negotiations.

  5. 5

    Would you be able to share the repair receipt or a breakdown of the work?

    A polite way to ask for proof and details about a repair charge. “Would you be able to” makes the request sound considerate and professional.

  6. 6

    If part of the work addressed the old scuff, I shouldn’t charge you for that.

    This uses a conditional to explain how the charge should change if some work covered pre-existing damage. It is a useful pattern for discussing responsibility fairly.

  7. 7

    Once we’ve reviewed the invoice and repair details, could you revise the itemized statement and let me know when I can expect the remaining refund?

    This links a requested next step to a clear question about timing. You can adapt it when you need someone to update a document and confirm when payment will arrive.

  8. 8

    If the charges aren’t supported, I’ll remove or reduce them before sending the refund.

    This conditional sentence explains what action will follow if the evidence does not justify the charges. It is useful for stating a fair decision and next step.

Enjoying English Dialogue?

A quick rating in the Microsoft Store helps other learners find the app.