Receiving the Deduction List

David sends Emma an itemized list of deductions from her security deposit. Emma compares the charges with her photos, lease, and move-in checklist, and spots a fee she believes is unfair.

Dialogue10

Receiving the Deduction List
David
David

Hi, Emma. I’ve finished reviewing the move-out inspection, and I’m sending you the itemized deduction list now. The remaining balance will be returned by Friday.

Emma
Emma

Thanks, David. I’ve just opened it. Could you walk me through the $240 cleaning fee? I left the apartment clean, and I have photos from the day I returned the keys.

David
David

The cleaner reported that the oven and bathroom needed additional work. We had the apartment professionally cleaned before the next tenant moved in, so I included the full invoice.

Emma
Emma

I understand wanting the place ready for the next tenant, but routine turnover cleaning isn’t necessarily the same as cleaning beyond normal use. My move-in checklist also notes the oven was stained when I arrived.

David
David

That’s fair to raise. I’ll check the checklist again. There’s also a $95 charge to repaint the living-room wall, where the inspector noted several scuffs near the sofa.

Emma
Emma

I took pictures of that wall when I moved in, and the same scuffs are visible. I can send you the original files with their dates, along with the checklist, so we can compare them.

David
David

Please do. The inspection form says there were marks, but it doesn’t specify where they were. If your photos show those exact scuffs were already there, that would affect the repainting charge.

Emma
Emma

I also noticed a $60 charge for replacing a kitchen drawer handle. It was loose during the walkthrough, and we noted it on the inspection form. Was there a repair invoice for that?

David
David

I’ll look for the receipt and check the walkthrough notes. I don’t want to charge you for something that was already documented, but I need to confirm what the repair actually involved.

Emma
Emma

I appreciate that. I’ll email the dated photos and my copy of the move-in checklist today. Could you hold off on finalizing those disputed deductions until you’ve had a chance to review them?

Vocabulary7

  • itemized deduction list

    A detailed list showing each amount taken from a deposit and the reason for it. You can ask for an itemized list when you want to understand specific charges.

  • walk me through

    Explain something step by step. Use this phrase when you want someone to clarify a bill, process, or decision.

  • routine turnover cleaning

    Ordinary cleaning done between tenants. In this context, Emma distinguishes it from cleaning needed because of unusual dirt or damage.

  • beyond normal use

    More wear or mess than would usually result from living in a place. This phrase can help explain why a charge may or may not be justified.

  • move-in checklist

    A record of the property's condition when a tenant first moves in. It can be used later to compare the original condition with the move-out condition.

  • dated photos

    Photos that show when they were taken. They can help establish that a mark or problem existed at a particular time.

  • hold off on

    Delay doing something for a while. You can use it to politely ask someone to wait before making a decision or taking action.

Key Sentences7

  1. 1

    Could you walk me through the $240 cleaning fee?

    A polite way to ask someone to explain a specific charge. Replace the fee or subject to ask about another item on a bill.

  2. 2

    I left the apartment clean, and I have photos from the day I returned the keys.

    This sentence presents your position and points to evidence that supports it. You can use the same structure when explaining a disagreement about a service or property.

  3. 3

    Routine turnover cleaning isn’t necessarily the same as cleaning beyond normal use.

    This carefully worded sentence makes a distinction without sounding overly confrontational. Use “isn’t necessarily the same as” to question whether two things should be treated alike.

  4. 4

    I can send you the original files with their dates, along with the checklist, so we can compare them.

    A useful way to offer evidence and suggest a practical next step. You can adapt it when sharing documents or records to resolve a disagreement.

  5. 5

    If your photos show those exact scuffs were already there, that would affect the repainting charge.

    This uses a conditional to explain how evidence could change a decision. Use “If …, that would affect …” to discuss possible consequences in a negotiation.

  6. 6

    I don’t want to charge you for something that was already documented, but I need to confirm what the repair actually involved.

    This acknowledges the other person’s concern while explaining why more checking is needed. The pattern “I don’t want to …, but I need to …” can help keep a discussion fair and professional.

  7. 7

    Could you hold off on finalizing those disputed deductions until you’ve had a chance to review them?

    A polite request asking someone to delay a decision until they have examined the evidence. “Hold off on” is useful in negotiations and other situations where you need more time.

Enjoying English Dialogue?

A quick rating in the Microsoft Store helps other learners find the app.