Talking With Residents Who Disagree

與持不同意見的居民交談

After the hearing, Jack talks with Leo, who supports the development and worries that added conditions could delay much-needed housing. They exchange views candidly and look for common ground on keeping the project accountable.

聽證會結束後,Jack 與支援該專案的 Leo 交談。Leo 擔心增加限制條件會拖延迫切需要的住房建設。兩人坦誠交流,並設法在監督專案落實方面尋找共識。

對話10

Talking With Residents Who Disagree
Jack
Jack

Leo, I’m glad you stayed. I know you support the project, and I’m not asking you to abandon that. I just want to understand what makes the proposed safeguards feel like a threat to the housing plan.

Leo,很高興你還沒走。我知道你支援這個專案,也不是要你放棄支援。我只是想了解,為什麼你覺得擬議中的保障措施會威脅到住房計劃。

Leo
Leo

Because every extra condition can become another review, another delay, and another year people spend searching for an affordable place. The housing shortage isn’t abstract to them; it’s already shaping their lives.

因為每增加一項條件,都可能多一次審查、多一段拖延,讓人們再多花一年尋找負擔得起的住處。住房短缺對他們來說並非抽象問題;它已經在影響他們的生活。

Jack
Jack

That’s fair. But the plan adds a lot of residents without showing how nearby streets or public services will absorb the impact. If those pressures are predictable, shouldn’t the project address them before construction?

你說得有道理。不過,計劃會增加不少居民,卻沒有說明附近街道或公共服務要如何承受這些影響。如果這些壓力可以預見,專案不該在開工前就想辦法應對嗎?

Leo
Leo

It should, but I worry about vague demands that keep expanding. If the council requires a traffic study, then rejects it, then asks for a different one, the developer can’t plan—and the homes don’t get built.

應該應對,但我擔心要求含糊不清,還不斷增加。要是市議會先要求交通研究,之後又否決,再要求做另一份,開發商就無法規劃,住房也建不起來。

Jack
Jack

I agree the conditions need clear limits. What if they’re tied to measurable outcomes—like completing the intersection upgrades before residents move in, rather than leaving the timing open-ended?

我同意這些條件需要有明確界限。要是把條件和可衡量的結果掛鉤呢?比如規定居民入住前必須完成路口改造,而不是讓時間安排沒有定數。

Leo
Leo

That sounds more reasonable. I’d still want to know who pays. If the developer has to cover every public improvement, those costs could be passed on through higher rents or used to justify building fewer units.

這樣聽起來更合理。不過,我還是想知道費用由誰承擔。如果所有公共設施改造都要開發商出錢,成本可能會轉嫁到更高的租金上,或者被用來當作減少住房數量的理由。

Jack
Jack

That’s a real risk. Maybe the city could identify which upgrades are directly required by the project, set a cost-sharing formula, and disclose it publicly so residents can see what’s being funded and why.

這確實是個風險。也許市政府可以明確哪些改造是專案直接造成的,制定費用分攤辦法,並公開相關資訊,讓居民知道資金用在何處、原因是什麼。

Leo
Leo

I could support that, provided it doesn’t turn into an indefinite negotiation. The project needs a firm approval path, and the city should publish deadlines for each review so everyone is accountable.

如果不會因此陷入無休止的協商,我可以支援。專案需要明確的審批流程,市政府也應該公佈每項審查的時限,讓各方都承擔責任。

Jack
Jack

That’s close to what I’m asking for: not a veto, but a plan with enforceable commitments and a transparent schedule. If the developer meets those commitments, the neighborhood should be able to hold the city to its deadlines, too.

這和我的訴求很接近:不是要否決專案,而是要一份包含可執行承諾和透明時間表的計劃。如果開發商履行了承諾,社群也應該能要求市政府遵守期限。

Leo
Leo

I can get behind that. We may still disagree about how much change the plan needs, but we both want the homes built without making existing problems worse. That’s a useful place to start.

這個我可以支援。我們或許仍會對計劃需要修改多少意見不同,但我們都希望住房建成,同時不讓現有問題惡化。這是個不錯的共同起點。

詞彙8

  • abandon that放棄支援

    To give up or stop supporting something. Here, Jack reassures Leo that he is not asking him to stop supporting the housing project.

    指放棄或不再支援某件事。這裡傑克是在向利奧保證,他並不是要利奧停止支援住房專案。

  • safeguards保障措施

    Measures intended to prevent harm or protect people. In this discussion, they are conditions meant to address the project’s effects on the neighborhood.

    指旨在防止傷害或保護人們的措施。在這段討論中,它們是為了應對專案對周邊社群影響而提出的條件。

  • vague demands含糊不清的要求

    Requests that are unclear and do not specify exactly what is required. Leo worries these could keep changing and cause delays.

    指沒有明確說明具體要求是什麼的請求。利奧擔心這些要求可能不斷變化,導致專案延期。

  • tied to measurable outcomes與可衡量的結果掛鉤

    Connected to results that can be clearly observed or assessed. This phrase is useful when proposing conditions with specific, verifiable goals.

    指與能夠清楚觀察或評估的結果相聯絡。提出具體、可核實的條件時,這個說法很實用。

  • passed on through higher rents透過提高租金轉嫁

    Transferred to someone else as an added cost. Leo is concerned that developers might cover improvement costs by charging tenants more.

    指把額外費用轉由別人承擔。利奧擔心開發商可能會透過提高租金來支付改造費用。

  • cost-sharing formula費用分攤辦法

    A defined method for deciding how different parties divide expenses. Jack suggests making the division of public improvement costs clear.

    指確定各方如何分擔費用的具體方法。傑克建議明確公共設施改造費用的分攤方式。

  • firm approval path明確的審批流程

    A clear, reliable process for obtaining official permission, with steps that do not keep changing. Leo wants the project to have one.

    指清晰、可靠的官方審批流程,各個步驟不會一再改變。利奧希望專案能有這樣一套流程。

  • hold the city to its deadlines要求市政府遵守期限

    Require the city to meet the deadlines it has promised. The phrase emphasizes that accountability should apply to the city as well as the developer.

    指要求市政府按承諾的期限辦事。這個說法強調,市政府和開發商一樣,都應該承擔責任。

關鍵句8

  1. 1

    I know you support the project, and I’m not asking you to abandon that.

    我知道你支援這個專案,也不是要你放棄支援。

    This acknowledges another person’s position before raising a concern. Use the pattern “I know you [view], and I’m not asking you to abandon that” to keep a disagreement respectful.

    這句話先承認對方的立場,再提出自己的顧慮。可以用句型 “I know you [view], and I’m not asking you to abandon that”(我知道你[持有某種看法],也不是要你放棄這一點),讓意見不合時仍能保持尊重。

  2. 2

    The housing shortage isn’t abstract to them; it’s already shaping their lives.

    住房短缺對他們來說並非抽象問題;它已經在影響他們的生活。

    This emphasizes that a broad issue has immediate, personal consequences. Use “isn’t abstract” to show that a problem is real and affecting people directly.

    這句話強調一個廣泛的問題會帶來迫切而具體的個人影響。用 “isn’t abstract” 表明問題是真實存在的,而且正在直接影響人們。

  3. 3

    If those pressures are predictable, shouldn’t the project address them before construction?

    如果這些壓力可以預見,專案不該在開工前就想辦法應對嗎?

    This uses a conditional question to make a reasoned case for taking action early. Reuse it to ask whether foreseeable effects should be addressed before a plan moves forward.

    這是用條件疑問句來說明為什麼應該儘早採取行動。你可以用這個句型詢問:計劃推進之前,是否應該先處理那些可以預見的影響。

  4. 4

    What if they’re tied to measurable outcomes—like completing the intersection upgrades before residents move in, rather than leaving the timing open-ended?

    要是把條件和可衡量的結果掛鉤呢?比如規定居民入住前必須完成路口改造,而不是讓時間安排沒有定數。

    This offers a practical compromise by suggesting specific results and a deadline. Use “What if…?” to propose a solution without presenting it as an ultimatum.

    這句話透過提出具體成果和期限,給出了一個切實可行的折中方案。用 “What if…?”(要是……呢?)提出解決辦法,聽起來不像是在下最後通牒。

  5. 5

    Maybe the city could identify which upgrades are directly required by the project, set a cost-sharing formula, and disclose it publicly so residents can see what’s being funded and why.

    也許市政府可以明確哪些改造是專案直接造成的,制定費用分攤辦法,並公開相關資訊,讓居民知道資金用在何處、原因是什麼。

    This sentence lays out a multi-part proposal and explains how transparency could help. The structure “Maybe [group] could…” is useful for offering a constructive policy suggestion.

    這句話提出了由多個部分組成的方案,並解釋了透明公開的好處。句型 “Maybe [group] could…”(也許[某一方]可以……)適合用來提出有建設性的政策建議。

  6. 6

    I could support that, provided it doesn’t turn into an indefinite negotiation.

    如果不會因此陷入無休止的協商,我可以支援。

    This expresses conditional agreement while clearly stating a limit. Use “I could support that, provided…” to show willingness to compromise if a condition is met.

    這句話表示有條件地同意,同時清楚說明了底線。用 “I could support that, provided…”(如果……,我可以支援)表達願意妥協,但前提是滿足某項條件。

  7. 7

    That’s close to what I’m asking for: not a veto, but a plan with enforceable commitments and a transparent schedule.

    這和我的訴求很接近:不是要否決專案,而是要一份包含可執行承諾和透明時間表的計劃。

    This clarifies the speaker’s position and distinguishes a practical request from a more extreme one. The structure “not [extreme action], but [reasonable alternative]” can help prevent misunderstandings.

    這句話說明了說話者的立場,並區分了實際訴求和更極端的做法。句型 “not [extreme action], but [reasonable alternative]”(不是[極端做法],而是[合理的替代方案])有助於避免誤解。

  8. 8

    We may still disagree about how much change the plan needs, but we both want the homes built without making existing problems worse.

    我們或許仍會對計劃需要修改多少意見不同,但我們都希望住房建成,同時不讓現有問題惡化。

    This recognizes an ongoing disagreement while identifying shared goals. Use “We may still disagree about…, but we both…” to find common ground without pretending that differences have disappeared.

    這句話承認雙方仍有分歧,同時指出彼此共同的目標。用 “We may still disagree about…, but we both…”(我們或許仍會對……意見不同,但我們都……)尋找共識,不必假裝分歧已經消失。

喜歡《English Dialogue》嗎?

在 Microsoft Store 留下簡短評分,能幫助其他學習者找到這款應用程式。