Preparing a Two-Minute Statement

準備兩分鐘陳述

Grace helps Mia shape a concise, persuasive statement that acknowledges the need for housing while arguing for specific safeguards. They rehearse how to make the case clearly within the time limit.

Grace 幫助 Mia 準備一份簡潔而有說服力的陳述:既承認住房需求,也主張採取具體保障措施。她們練習如何在規定時間內清楚表達觀點。

對話11

Preparing a Two-Minute Statement
Grace
Grace

You have two minutes, Mia, so we need a clear through line: acknowledge the housing shortage, then explain why the current plan needs safeguards—not abandonment.

你只有兩分鐘,米婭,所以我們得有一條清晰的主線:先承認住房短缺,再說明為什麼現有方案需要保障措施,而不是被全盤放棄。

Mia
Mia

I want to avoid sounding like I’m simply against change. The project could bring much-needed homes, but the added traffic and loss of mature trees would affect the whole neighborhood.

我不想讓人覺得我只是在反對改變。這個專案能帶來急需的住房,但交通量增加和成熟樹木被砍,會影響整個社群。

Grace
Grace

Good. Lead with that balance. Then name two or three concrete protections, not a catalogue of every concern. Which changes would make the greatest difference?

很好。就從這種平衡的態度切入。然後提出兩三項具體保障措施,不要把所有擔憂都羅列一遍。哪些改動最能帶來實質影響?

Mia
Mia

A binding traffic plan before construction, protected replacement trees, and a commitment to improve the bus stop and pedestrian crossings nearby. Those are specific enough to be assessed.

開工前制定有約束力的交通方案,保護現有樹木並補種替代樹木,還要承諾改善附近的公交站和人行橫道。這些要求足夠具體,也便於評估。

Grace
Grace

That’s persuasive, but be careful with “replacement trees.” Newly planted trees won’t provide the shade or habitat we’d lose for decades. Ask them to preserve the largest trees wherever feasible.

這個論點有說服力,不過要謹慎使用“補種樹木”這個說法。新栽的樹幾十年內都無法提供我們將失去的樹蔭和棲息地。要求他們在可行的情況下保留最大、最成熟的樹木。

Mia
Mia

Right. I’ll say preservation should be the default, with replacement planting only where removal is unavoidable. I also want to explain that safer crossings matter to older residents and children.

對。我會說,原則上應優先保留樹木,只有在無法避免砍伐時才補種。我還想說明,更安全的人行橫道對年長居民和孩子都很重要。

Grace
Grace

You can make that point without implying the current design ignores them. Try: “Please require a safety review that includes the people who use these streets every day.”

你可以提出這一點,但別讓人覺得現有設計完全沒有考慮他們。試著這樣說:“請要求開展安全評估,並聽取每天使用這些街道的人的意見。”

Mia
Mia

Let me try the opening: “I support adding housing, and I’m asking the council to approve a plan that works for both future residents and the neighbors already here.”

我來試試開場:“我支援增加住房,也請市議會批准一項既能滿足未來居民需求、又能照顧現有鄰居的方案。”

Grace
Grace

Strong. Now trim the middle, and end with a direct request. Don’t say the council should “consider” safeguards; ask it to make them conditions of approval.

很好。現在把中間部分再精簡些,並用明確的請求收尾。別隻說市議會應該“考慮”這些保障措施;要要求把它們列為批准專案的條件。

Mia
Mia

Understood. I’ll say the project should move forward only with enforceable traffic and pedestrian-safety measures, and meaningful tree preservation. Is that within two minutes?

明白。我會說,只有落實可執行的交通與行人安全措施,並切實保護樹木,專案才能繼續推進。這樣能控制在兩分鐘內嗎?

Grace
Grace

At your pace, yes—just under. Pause after your opening, keep the requests in a short list, and leave the council with one clear choice: improve the plan, don’t dismiss the need for housing.

按你的語速,可以,時間剛剛夠。開場後停頓一下,把訴求簡短列出,最後給市議會一個清晰的選擇:完善方案,而不是忽視住房需求。

詞彙8

  • clear through line清晰的主線

    The main idea that connects the parts of a speech. Here, it means organizing the statement around supporting housing while asking for safeguards.

    指貫穿演講各部分的核心思想。這裡指圍繞支援增加住房、同時要求採取保障措施來組織陳述。

  • safeguards保障措施

    Measures that reduce risks or prevent harm. In this context, they are protections for traffic safety, pedestrians, and trees.

    指降低風險或避免造成傷害的措施。在這裡,指保障交通安全、行人安全和樹木的措施。

  • a catalogue of every concern把所有擔憂一一羅列

    A long list of all the issues someone has. The phrase suggests choosing the most important points instead of overwhelming listeners.

    指把所有問題都長篇列出來。這個說法提醒我們要挑選最重要的幾點,而不是讓聽眾應接不暇。

  • binding traffic plan有約束力的交通方案

    A traffic plan that must be followed, rather than a voluntary suggestion. “Binding” emphasizes that the protection should be enforceable.

    指必須遵守的交通方案,而不是自願採納的建議。“Binding”強調這項保障措施應當可以強制執行。

  • wherever feasible在可行的情況下

    As much as is practical or possible. This phrase helps make a request firm while recognizing that circumstances may limit what can be done.

    指在實際或條件允許的範圍內儘可能做到。這個說法既能讓請求明確有力,也承認具體情況可能會限制可採取的措施。

  • conditions of approval批准條件

    Requirements that must be met for a project to receive approval. The phrase makes clear that safeguards should be mandatory, not merely considered.

    指專案獲批前必須滿足的要求。這個說法明確表明,保障措施應當是強制要求,而不只是供人考慮的建議。

  • enforceable可強制執行的

    Able to be officially required and upheld. Here, it means the traffic and safety measures should have practical consequences if they are not followed.

    指可以由官方要求並予以落實。在這裡,指如果沒有遵守交通和安全措施,就應當產生實際後果。

  • move forward繼續推進

    To proceed with a plan or project. In this dialogue, it is paired with conditions that should be met before the project proceeds.

    指繼續實施某項計劃或專案。在這段對話中,它與專案推進前必須滿足的條件搭配使用。

關鍵句8

  1. 1

    You have two minutes, Mia, so we need a clear through line: acknowledge the housing shortage, then explain why the current plan needs safeguards—not abandonment.

    你只有兩分鐘,米婭,所以我們得有一條清晰的主線:先承認住房短缺,再說明為什麼現有方案需要保障措施,而不是被全盤放棄。

    This sentence gives a concise structure for a persuasive statement and balances agreement with criticism. Reuse the pattern “acknowledge X, then explain why Y” to present a nuanced argument.

    這句話為有說服力的陳述提供了簡潔的結構,同時兼顧認同與批評。你可以套用“先承認 X,再說明為什麼 Y”的句式,表達更周全的觀點。

  2. 2

    The project could bring much-needed homes, but the added traffic and loss of mature trees would affect the whole neighborhood.

    這個專案能帶來急需的住房,但交通量增加和成熟樹木被砍,會影響整個社群。

    This sentence recognizes a benefit before introducing potential costs. Use “could bring X, but Y would affect…” to make a balanced case.

    這句話先承認益處,再提出可能帶來的代價。你可以用“could bring X, but Y would affect…”來平衡地闡述觀點。

  3. 3

    A binding traffic plan before construction, protected replacement trees, and a commitment to improve the bus stop and pedestrian crossings nearby.

    開工前制定有約束力的交通方案,保護樹木並補種替代樹木,還要承諾改善附近的公交站和人行橫道。

    This is a focused list of concrete requests. Use a short series of specific actions to make a proposal easier for decision-makers to assess.

    這是一個簡明具體的訴求清單。用一連串具體行動來表達提議,能讓決策者更容易評估。

  4. 4

    Please require a safety review that includes the people who use these streets every day.

    請要求開展安全評估,並聽取每天使用這些街道的人的意見。

    This is a direct but respectful request that also identifies whose experience should inform the review. Reuse “Please require a review that includes…” when asking officials to consider affected communities.

    這是一個直接而有禮貌的請求,也指出了評估應參考哪些人的經驗。向官員提出應考慮受影響社群的意見時,可以套用“Please require a review that includes…”的句式。

  5. 5

    I support adding housing, and I’m asking the council to approve a plan that works for both future residents and the neighbors already here.

    我支援增加住房,也請市議會批准一項既能滿足未來居民需求、又能照顧現有鄰居的方案。

    This opening states support for the broader goal while advocating for a better plan. It is useful when you want to show you are proposing improvements, not opposing change outright.

    這句話在表明支援總體目標的同時,也倡導改進方案。當你想讓人知道自己是在提出改進建議、而不是一味反對改變時,可以用這樣的開場。

  6. 6

    Don’t say the council should “consider” safeguards; ask it to make them conditions of approval.

    別說市議會應該“考慮”這些保障措施;要要求把它們列為批准專案的條件。

    This sentence highlights the difference between a suggestion and a binding requirement. Use “make them conditions of approval” when you need proposed protections to be mandatory.

    這句話強調了建議與有約束力的要求之間的區別。當你需要讓擬議的保障措施成為強制要求時,可以用“make them conditions of approval”。

  7. 7

    I’ll say the project should move forward only with enforceable traffic and pedestrian-safety measures, and meaningful tree preservation.

    我會說,只有落實可強制執行的交通與行人安全措施,並切實保護樹木,專案才能繼續推進。

    This sentence clearly states the conditions for supporting a project. Reuse “should move forward only with…” to make support conditional on specific protections.

    這句話清楚地說明了支援專案的前提條件。你可以用“should move forward only with…”來表示,只有採取特定保障措施,才支援專案繼續推進。

  8. 8

    Pause after your opening, keep the requests in a short list, and leave the council with one clear choice: improve the plan, don’t dismiss the need for housing.

    開場後停頓一下,把訴求簡短列出,最後給市議會一個清晰的選擇:完善方案,而不是忽視住房需求。

    This is practical guidance for delivering a concise, persuasive speech. The final contrast helps listeners remember the speaker’s central point.

    這是關於如何發表簡潔而有說服力的陳述的實用建議。最後的對比能幫助聽眾記住說話者的核心觀點。

喜歡《English Dialogue》嗎?

在 Microsoft Store 留下簡短評分,能幫助其他學習者找到這款應用程式。