Negotiating Scope Cuts

協商縮減專案範圍

The committee asks Mia to reduce the request without undermining the project’s core purpose. She proposes phasing one optional activity and trimming travel costs while protecting staffing for essential services.

委員會要求Mia縮減申請金額,但不能損害專案的核心目標。她提出分階段開展一項非必要活動,並削減差旅費用,同時保留核心服務所需的人員配置。

對話11

Negotiating Scope Cuts
Grace
Grace

We’ve reviewed the proposal, Mia. To bring the request closer to the available ceiling, we need a meaningful reduction—not a cosmetic adjustment. What could you scale back without compromising the project’s purpose?

我們已經審閱了這份提案,Mia。為了讓申請金額更接近現有預算上限,我們需要實質性削減,而不是做表面調整。你們可以縮減哪些內容,又不損害專案宗旨?

Mia
Mia

The core is the weekly service and the follow-up support; those are what make the intervention effective. I’d propose phasing the optional community showcase into a later funding period rather than cutting it outright.

核心是每週服務和後續支援;正是這些環節讓干預措施真正有效。我建議把可選的社群成果展示推遲到後續資助期,而不是直接取消。

David
David

That may defer costs, but it doesn’t necessarily reduce this year’s request. What would you remove from the current budget, and how much would that actually save?

這或許能推遲支出,但未必能降低今年的申請金額。你會從當前預算中刪去哪些專案?實際能節省多少?

Mia
Mia

We can remove the venue rental, external production, and promotional materials for the showcase. That would reduce the current request by roughly twelve thousand dollars, while preserving the option to revisit it if additional funds become available.

我們可以取消成果展示的場地租賃、外部製作和宣傳材料。這樣當前申請金額大約能減少一萬兩千美元,同時保留日後獲得額外資金時重新考慮的可能。

Grace
Grace

And travel? The committee sees several trips listed. Some appear useful, but are they all necessary for delivering the service?

那差旅呢?委員會看到預算中列了好幾次出行。有些似乎有用,但它們是否都是提供服務所必需的?

Mia
Mia

Not all of them. We can consolidate partner meetings, use remote check-ins where appropriate, and cap reimbursable travel at the lowest reasonable rate. I wouldn’t recommend eliminating site visits entirely; they’re important for quality assurance.

並非每次都必不可少。我們可以合併合作方會議,在適當情況下改為遠端溝通,並將可報銷差旅費用控制在合理的最低水平。我不建議完全取消現場走訪;它們對質量保障很重要。

David
David

I’m still concerned that “lowest reasonable rate” leaves room for interpretation. Can you put a concrete limit on travel, rather than relying on a general assurance?

我仍然擔心,“合理的最低水平”有多種解釋。你能為差旅費設定一個明確上限,而不是隻作籠統保證嗎?

Mia
Mia

Yes. We can set a fixed travel ceiling and require advance approval for any exception. If costs exceed that cap, we’ll absorb the difference or seek written authorization before reallocating funds.

可以。我們可以設定固定的差旅費上限,任何例外情況都必須事先獲批。如果費用超過上限,我們會自行承擔差額,或在重新分配資金前取得書面授權。

Grace
Grace

That’s more specific. But I want to be clear: staffing for the weekly service is not on the table for reduction. Are you confident the revised scope is still deliverable?

這樣就明確多了。但我想說明一點:每週服務所需的人員經費不能再削減。你有把握按修訂後的範圍完成專案嗎?

Mia
Mia

Yes. We’ve protected the staffing hours tied directly to service delivery and follow-up. The revised plan postpones an enhancement, not a core activity, and we’ll report the change transparently against the original objectives.

有把握。我們保留了直接用於服務實施和後續支援的工時。修訂後的計劃推遲的是一項拓展活動,而非核心工作;我們也會對照原定目標如實報告這一變更。

David
David

Then please submit the revised budget with the travel cap and the phased showcase clearly identified. We’ll assess the request on that basis, including whether the remaining funds are sufficient for the essential work.

那就請提交修訂後的預算,並明確列出差旅費上限以及分階段開展成果展示的安排。我們會據此評估申請,包括剩餘資金是否足以支援核心工作。

詞彙7

  • a meaningful reduction實質性削減

    A substantial cut, not just a small or symbolic change. Here, the committee wants the budget request lowered by a noticeable amount.

    指大幅削減,而不只是小幅或象徵性的調整。在這裡,委員會希望申請金額有明顯下降。

  • current request當前申請金額

    The amount of funding being requested for the present period. It distinguishes this year’s budget from possible future funding.

    指本階段申請的資金數額,用來區別於未來可能獲得的資金。

  • consolidate partner meetings合併合作方會議

    Combine meetings so that fewer trips are needed. This is a practical way to reduce travel costs.

    把幾次會議合併起來,從而減少出行次數。這是降低差旅費用的一種實際做法。

  • quality assurance質量保障

    Checks that confirm a service is being delivered properly. Here, site visits help ensure the project maintains its standards.

    指確認服務是否得到妥善提供的一系列檢查。在這裡,現場走訪有助於確保專案維持既定標準。

  • fixed travel ceiling固定差旅費上限

    A specific maximum amount allowed for travel costs. A fixed limit makes the budget commitment clear and measurable.

    指差旅費用允許達到的明確最高金額。固定上限能讓預算承諾清晰且便於衡量。

  • advance approval事先批准

    Permission that must be obtained before taking an action. In this context, exceptions to the travel limit require approval beforehand.

    指在採取某項行動之前必須獲得的許可。在這裡,超出差旅費上限的例外情況需要事先獲批。

  • on the table在考慮範圍內

    Under consideration as a possible option. Saying staffing is “not on the table” means the committee is not considering cutting it.

    表示某個選項正在被考慮。說人員配置“not on the table”(不在考慮範圍內),意思是委員會不會考慮削減人員。

關鍵句7

  1. 1

    What could you scale back without compromising the project’s purpose?

    你們可以縮減哪些內容,又不損害專案宗旨?

    This asks someone to find savings while protecting the main goal. Reuse “What could you scale back without compromising ___?” when discussing careful reductions.

    這句話要求對方在保護主要目標的同時找出節省之處。討論謹慎削減時,可以重複使用“What could you scale back without compromising ___?”(在不損害___的情況下,你可以縮減哪些內容?)這一句式。

  2. 2

    I’d propose phasing the optional community showcase into a later funding period rather than cutting it outright.

    我建議把可選的社群成果展示安排到後續資助期,而不是直接取消。

    This presents a compromise: postpone an optional activity instead of canceling it. “I’d propose [option] rather than [alternative]” is useful for tactful negotiation.

    這句話提出了一種折中方案:推遲一項非必要活動,而不是取消它。“I’d propose [option] rather than [alternative]”適合在委婉協商時提出建議。

  3. 3

    We can consolidate partner meetings, use remote check-ins where appropriate, and cap reimbursable travel at the lowest reasonable rate.

    我們可以合併合作方會議,在適當情況下改為遠端溝通,並將可報銷差旅費用控制在合理的最低水平。

    This sentence offers several specific ways to control travel costs. Reuse the parallel structure to list practical steps in a professional discussion.

    這句話提出了幾種控制差旅費用的具體辦法。在專業討論中,可以重複使用這種並列結構來列出切實可行的步驟。

  4. 4

    I wouldn’t recommend eliminating site visits entirely; they’re important for quality assurance.

    我不建議完全取消現場走訪;它們對質量保障很重要。

    This explains why a complete cut would create a risk, while still allowing other reductions. “I wouldn’t recommend [action]; [reason]” is a measured way to disagree.

    這句話說明完全削減會帶來風險,同時也表明其他方面仍可以削減。“I wouldn’t recommend [action]; [reason]”是一種經過斟酌的不同意表達方式。

  5. 5

    If costs exceed that cap, we’ll absorb the difference or seek written authorization before reallocating funds.

    如果費用超過這個上限,我們會自行承擔差額,或在重新分配資金前取得書面授權。

    This clarifies what will happen if spending goes over the limit. The conditional structure is useful for stating a policy and its exception process.

    這句話說明支出超過上限時將如何處理。這種條件句結構適合用來說明政策及其例外處理流程。

  6. 6

    The revised plan postpones an enhancement, not a core activity, and we’ll report the change transparently against the original objectives.

    修訂後的計劃推遲的是一項拓展活動,而非核心工作;我們會對照原定目標如實報告這一變更。

    This reassures the committee that the project’s essential work remains protected and that changes will be documented. Reuse “not a core activity” to distinguish optional work from essential work.

    這句話向委員會保證,專案的核心工作仍受到保護,而且所有變更都會被記錄。“not a core activity”可以用來區分可選工作和必要工作。

  7. 7

    We’ll assess the request on that basis, including whether the remaining funds are sufficient for the essential work.

    我們會據此評估申請,包括剩餘資金是否足以支援核心工作。

    This describes how a decision will be made and identifies the key criterion. “Assess [something] on that basis” is useful when referring to agreed conditions or evidence.

    這句話說明將如何作出決定,並指出關鍵標準。“Assess [something] on that basis”適合在提及已經同意的條件或依據時使用。

喜歡《English Dialogue》嗎?

在 Microsoft Store 留下簡短評分,能幫助其他學習者找到這款應用程式。