Defending the Project’s Impact
闡明專案的影響
When the committee questions whether the project’s outcomes justify its cost, Mia explains who will benefit and how results will be assessed. Grace presses her to distinguish essential outcomes from more ambitious promises.
委員會質疑專案成果是否足以證明其成本合理,Mia於是說明受益物件以及評估成果的方式。Grace要求她區分必不可少的成果與更具雄心的承諾。
對話12

Mia, the committee understands the project is valuable, but the projected cost per participant is substantial. What evidence suggests the outcomes will justify that investment?
Mia,委員會理解這個專案很有價值,但預計的人均成本相當高。有什麼證據表明專案成果足以證明這筆投入是合理的?
That figure reflects the full cost of delivering the program, including outreach and follow-up—not simply the cost of a workshop. We expect to serve 120 participants over the grant period.
這個數字涵蓋了專案實施的全部成本,包括招募和後續跟進,並不只是舉辦一場研討會的費用。我們預計在資助期內為120名參與者提供服務。
Serving 120 people is an output, not necessarily an impact. What concrete change do you expect to see, and how will you distinguish it from what would have happened anyway?
服務120人是產出,不一定代表實際影響。你們預計會帶來哪些具體改變?又將如何判斷這些改變確實由專案促成,而不是本來就會發生?
We’ll track whether participants complete the required application process and gain access to the services they were previously unable to navigate. We’ll compare baseline and follow-up data, then report completion rates.
我們會追蹤參與者是否完成相關申請流程,以及是否成功獲得他們此前難以申請到的服務。我們將比較基線資料與後續資料,並報告完成率。
Completion rates are useful, but access can mean different things. Are you promising that participants will secure services, or only that they’ll submit applications?
完成率很有參考價值,但“獲得服務”可能有不同含義。你們承諾的是參與者最終能獲得服務,還是僅僅提交申請?
That’s an important distinction. We can commit to documenting successful access where agencies provide the data, but we can’t guarantee approval decisions made by outside providers.
這個區別很重要。如果相關機構提供資料,我們可以承諾記錄參與者是否成功獲得服務,但無法保證由外部服務機構作出的審批結果。
Then define success in terms you control. Otherwise, the final report could look disappointing even if your team performs well. Which outcomes are essential, rather than aspirational?
那就用你們能夠掌控的指標來界定成功。否則,即使團隊表現出色,最終報告也可能顯得不理想。哪些成果是必須實現的,哪些只是更積極的目標?
Essentially, we’ll provide individualized guidance, help participants complete applications, and document referrals. Our more ambitious aim is to see a measurable increase in successful access across the cohort.
基本目標是提供個性化指導、協助參與者完成申請,並記錄轉介情況。更具挑戰性的目標,則是觀察到整個群體成功獲得服務的比例有所提高。
That’s clearer. How will you account for participants who leave the program early or can’t be reached for follow-up? Those gaps could skew the results.
這樣就清楚多了。對於提前退出專案或無法聯絡進行後續跟蹤的參與者,你們會如何處理?這些資料缺口可能會影響結果。
We’ll report attrition separately, describe the limits it creates, and avoid treating missing follow-up as either success or failure. We’ll also review patterns in who disengages.
我們會單獨報告退出人數,說明由此產生的侷限,並且不會把缺失的後續資料簡單算作成功或失敗。我們還會分析哪些參與者更容易中斷參與。
And if the evidence shows the model isn’t working as intended, will you adjust the program—or are you committed to delivering the activities exactly as proposed?
如果證據表明專案模式沒有達到預期,你們會調整方案嗎?還是仍會完全按照提案中的安排執行?
We’ll preserve the core service while adapting delivery in response to the findings. The grant would fund a testable model, not lock us into a format that the evidence tells us to reconsider.
我們會保留核心服務,同時根據評估結果調整實施方式。這筆資助支援的是一個可檢驗的模式,而不是要求我們死守一個證據表明需要重新審視的方案。
詞彙7
- cost per participant人均成本
The average amount spent to serve one person. Here, the committee uses it to assess whether the project’s results justify its expense.
為一人提供服務的平均支出。這裡,委員會用這個數字來評估專案成果是否值得這筆開支。
- baseline and follow-up data基線資料和後續資料
Information collected before a program begins and again afterward. Comparing the two can help show what changed during the project.
專案開始前收集的資訊,以及專案開始後再次收集的資訊。比較這兩組資料,有助於瞭解專案期間發生了哪些變化。
- completion rates完成率
The proportion of participants who finish a required process or activity. In this context, it measures how many complete their applications.
完成某項規定流程或活動的參與者所佔的比例。在這裡,它衡量的是有多少人完成了申請。
- aspirational理想化的;更具雄心的
Describing a goal that is hoped for but is not guaranteed. It helps distinguish ambitious aims from outcomes the project commits to deliver.
形容一個人們希望實現、但無法保證實現的目標。這個詞有助於區分更具雄心的目標與專案承諾實現的成果。
- account for考慮到;說明
To consider or explain something when assessing results. Here, Mia must account for participants who leave early or cannot be reached.
評估結果時,將某件事納入考慮或加以說明。這裡,米婭需要說明提前退出或無法聯絡到的參與者情況。
- attrition參與者流失
The loss of participants who stop taking part in a program or study. Reporting it separately helps readers understand gaps in the results.
停止參與某個專案或研究的參與者人數。單獨報告這一情況,有助於讀者理解結果中的資料缺口。
- in response to根據;作為對……的回應
As a reaction to something or because of it. Mia uses this phrase to explain that the team will adapt delivery based on what the findings show.
表示因某事而採取行動,或作為對某事的回應。米婭用這個短語說明,團隊會根據評估結果調整專案的實施方式。
關鍵句7
- 1
What evidence suggests the outcomes will justify that investment?
有什麼證據表明這些成果足以證明這筆投入是合理的?
This is a focused way to ask whether expected results are worth the cost. You can reuse the structure to evaluate a proposal, purchase, or policy: “What evidence suggests [benefit] will justify [cost]?”
這是一種直接的問法,用來詢問預期成果是否值得付出相應成本。你可以套用這個句型來評估提案、購買或政策:“What evidence suggests [benefit] will justify [cost]?”(有什麼證據表明[收益]足以證明[成本]是合理的?)
- 2
Serving 120 people is an output, not necessarily an impact.
服務120人是一項產出,但不一定代表實際影響。
This sentence distinguishes an activity or count from a meaningful change. It is useful when evaluating whether a project’s measurable results demonstrate real benefits.
這句話區分了活動或人數統計與有意義的改變。在評估專案的可衡量成果是否體現了實際益處時,這種說法很有用。
- 3
We’ll compare baseline and follow-up data, then report completion rates.
我們會比較基線資料和後續資料,然後報告完成率。
This explains a practical method for measuring progress. Reuse it to describe how you will compare results over time and communicate a specific measure.
這句話說明了一種切實可行的進展衡量方法。你可以用它來描述如何比較不同時期的結果,並彙報一項具體指標。
- 4
We can commit to documenting successful access where agencies provide the data, but we can’t guarantee approval decisions made by outside providers.
如果相關機構提供資料,我們可以承諾記錄參與者是否成功獲得服務,但無法保證外部服務機構作出的審批結果。
This sentence clearly separates what a team can promise from decisions beyond its control. It is useful for setting realistic expectations while still showing accountability.
這句話清楚地區分了團隊能夠承諾的事項與其無法控制的決定。在設定現實預期的同時展現責任心時,這種說法很有用。
- 5
Which outcomes are essential, rather than aspirational?
哪些成果是必不可少的,而不是更具雄心的目標?
This concise question asks someone to separate core commitments from hoped-for goals. Use it when clarifying the scope of a plan or proposal.
這個簡潔的問題旨在讓對方區分核心承諾與期望實現的目標。在明確計劃或提案的範圍時,可以使用這個問法。
- 6
We’ll report attrition separately, describe the limits it creates, and avoid treating missing follow-up as either success or failure.
我們會單獨報告參與者流失情況,說明由此造成的侷限,並避免將缺失的後續資料視為成功或失敗。
This is a careful way to explain how missing data will be handled without overstating conclusions. It is useful when discussing evaluation methods and their limitations.
這是一種謹慎的說法,說明如何處理缺失資料,同時避免誇大結論。在討論評估方法及其侷限時,這種表達很有用。
- 7
The grant would fund a testable model, not lock us into a format that the evidence tells us to reconsider.
這筆資助支援的是一個可檢驗的模式,而不是把我們束縛在一個證據表明需要重新審視的方案上。
This persuasive sentence frames funding as support for learning and responsible adaptation. You can reuse the contrast “fund [a testable approach], not lock us into [an inflexible plan]” when advocating for flexibility.
這句有說服力的話將資助定位為對學習和負責任調整的支援。你可以套用“fund [a testable approach], not lock us into [an inflexible plan]”(資助[一種可檢驗的方法],而不是把我們束縛在[一項僵化的計劃]上)這個對比句式,來爭取靈活調整的空間。