Reading the Reviews Together
The coauthors meet to read the reviewers’ comments on their manuscript. They sort the feedback into methodological concerns, requests for clarification, and minor revisions.
Dialogue12

Thanks for making time to go through the reviews together. I’ve read them once, but I’d like us to separate the substantive concerns from the requests that are mainly about presentation.
Agreed. I made a spreadsheet with each comment, the section it refers to, and a column for our initial assessment. I haven’t drafted any replies yet; I figured we should agree on the substance first.
Good. Let’s avoid treating every criticism as equally serious. Some comments may require additional analysis, while others may simply reveal that our explanation wasn’t clear enough to a careful reader.
The first reviewer questions how we defined the study population and whether our inclusion criteria could have excluded relevant cases. That sounds methodological, though we should check exactly what the reviewer is concerned about.
I read that as a request to clarify the recruitment process, not necessarily an argument that the sample itself is invalid. The comment asks for more detail about when participants were screened and by whom.
That distinction matters. Let’s mark it as methodological, but note that the likely remedy is clarification unless the reviewer identifies a specific source of bias. We shouldn’t concede a flaw we haven’t established.
There’s also a question about how we handled missing responses. We describe the procedure briefly in the methods section, but perhaps we never explain why that approach was appropriate for this dataset.
Right. I’d put that under clarification for now, with a note to verify the analysis details. If our rationale is sound, we can make it explicit; if not, we may need to revisit the method.
The remaining comments seem more straightforward: define two abbreviations, add a citation for an established measure, and correct a table note. Those are minor revisions, but they still deserve precise attention.
Then our first pass gives us three categories: methodological concerns to examine, points needing clearer explanation, and minor revisions. Jack, could you check the missing-data procedure while I review the population criteria?
Sure. I’ll compare the manuscript with our analysis notes so we don’t promise a change that contradicts what we actually did. Once we’ve checked the facts, we can decide how each point should be addressed.
Excellent. For now, let’s resist drafting defensive language. A careful classification gives us room to respond firmly where the evidence supports us and candidly where the manuscript needs improvement.
Vocabulary8
- substantive concerns
Important issues that affect the substance or validity of a study, rather than its wording or presentation. Use this phrase to distinguish major problems from minor editorial requests.
- initial assessment
An early judgment about a comment or situation, made before a final decision. It is useful when organizing feedback that still needs investigation.
- inclusion criteria
The rules used to decide which people or cases are eligible for a study. Researchers can explain these criteria when reviewers ask how the study population was selected.
- source of bias
A factor that may systematically distort research findings. Use this phrase when considering whether a method or selection process could have affected the results.
- missing responses
Answers or observations that were not provided or recorded. In research discussions, the phrase often refers to how incomplete data were handled.
- make it explicit
To state something clearly and directly rather than leaving it implied. Researchers can use this phrase when a reviewer needs a clearer explanation of the rationale for a method.
- minor revisions
Small changes to a manuscript, such as defining abbreviations or correcting a table note. The phrase distinguishes these edits from changes to the study’s methods or conclusions.
- candidly
In an open and honest way, without hiding a problem. It is useful when agreeing to acknowledge a genuine weakness in a manuscript.
Key Sentences7
- 1
I’ve read them once, but I’d like us to separate the substantive concerns from the requests that are mainly about presentation.
This tactfully proposes a way to organize feedback by importance. Reuse the structure “I’d like us to separate X from Y” when distinguishing different kinds of issues.
- 2
Some comments may require additional analysis, while others may simply reveal that our explanation wasn’t clear enough to a careful reader.
This sentence avoids assuming that every criticism points to a research flaw. Use “while others may simply…” to contrast more serious issues with problems of clarity.
- 3
That distinction matters.
This concise sentence emphasizes that two interpretations should not be treated as equivalent. Use it to signal that a difference in meaning or category will affect the next decision.
- 4
We shouldn’t concede a flaw we haven’t established.
This is a measured way to resist admitting a problem before checking the evidence. It is useful in professional discussions where a response needs to be both fair and precise.
- 5
If our rationale is sound, we can make it explicit; if not, we may need to revisit the method.
This sentence sets out two possible next steps depending on what the evidence shows. Reuse the “If X, …; if not, …” structure to describe a balanced decision process.
- 6
I’ll compare the manuscript with our analysis notes so we don’t promise a change that contradicts what we actually did.
This explains a practical safeguard before replying to reviewers. Use “so we don’t…” to describe how an action will prevent a specific mistake.
- 7
A careful classification gives us room to respond firmly where the evidence supports us and candidly where the manuscript needs improvement.
This summarizes how a well-organized response can be both confident and honest. The parallel structure “firmly where… and candidly where…” is useful for expressing a balanced approach.