Talking With the Journal Editor
The team speaks with the journal editor after a disagreement remains about the methodological criticism. They explain their revisions and evidence diplomatically, while asking whether the response adequately addresses the editor’s concerns.
Dialogue12

Thank you for making time to speak with us. We’ve revised the manuscript and prepared a point-by-point response, but we wanted to check whether we’ve addressed the concern about our sampling strategy adequately.
The central disagreement seems to be whether our recruitment process limits the conclusions we can draw, or whether the manuscript simply failed to explain the design clearly. We’ve tried to address both possibilities.
We clarified that participants were recruited through a defined set of sites, rather than selected to represent the broader population. We’ve also added a limitation stating that the findings may not generalize beyond those settings.
We also ran the sensitivity analyses requested in the review. The estimates shifted modestly under alternative specifications, but the direction and overall interpretation of the main finding remained stable.
That is useful evidence, though we’re careful not to present robustness as proof that the sampling concern is immaterial. It speaks to the stability of the analysis, not to representativeness.
Would you advise us to make that distinction more explicit in the response letter? We want to be clear about what the additional analyses establish without implying they resolve every aspect of the criticism.
I think that would help. We can acknowledge that the design narrows the scope of inference, then explain that the revised text states this plainly and that the sensitivity checks address a separate concern about analytical dependence.
That framing sounds balanced. My remaining question is whether the editor expects a further change to the manuscript itself, or whether the revised explanation and limitation are sufficient for this round.
We could add one sentence to the discussion explaining why the chosen sites were appropriate for the research question, while avoiding any claim that they capture the full range of relevant settings.
That seems proportionate. We’re not trying to win an argument with the reviewer; we want the manuscript to reflect the limits of the design and make the rationale transparent to readers.
Agreed. Make that targeted addition, and keep the response measured: thank the reviewer, summarize the changes, and distinguish the limitation from the point the sensitivity analyses can address.
We’ll do that. Thank you for clarifying what would be most useful; it gives us a constructive way to close the gap without overstating what the evidence supports.
Vocabulary8
- point-by-point response
A reply that addresses each comment or criticism separately. In this context, it is the authors’ organized response to the reviewers.
- scope of inference
The range of conclusions that the study’s evidence can reasonably support. Here, the sampling design limits how broadly the findings can be applied.
- generalize beyond those settings
Apply findings to places or groups outside the ones studied. This phrase helps describe a limitation without dismissing the value of the research.
- sensitivity analyses
Additional analyses that test whether results change under different assumptions or methods. They can show how stable results are, but do not necessarily resolve every methodological concern.
- representativeness
How well a sample reflects the broader population of interest. In this discussion, the authors distinguish it from the stability of their analysis.
- analytical dependence
The extent to which findings depend on particular analytical choices or assumptions. The authors explain that their sensitivity checks address this issue, not whether the sample represents a wider population.
- proportionate
Appropriate in size or extent to the issue being addressed. Here, it describes making a targeted manuscript change rather than responding excessively.
- overstating what the evidence supports
Making claims that go further than the research findings justify. This is a useful phrase for emphasizing careful, evidence-based communication.
Key Sentences8
- 1
We’ve revised the manuscript and prepared a point-by-point response, but we wanted to check whether we’ve addressed the concern about our sampling strategy adequately.
This politely introduces completed work while asking for feedback. Reuse the structure to summarize revisions and confirm whether a specific concern has been addressed.
- 2
We’ve tried to address both possibilities.
This concise sentence signals that the team has considered more than one interpretation of a criticism. Use it when responding to a concern with multiple possible causes.
- 3
That is useful evidence, though we’re careful not to present robustness as proof that the sampling concern is immaterial.
This acknowledges the value of evidence while clearly limiting what it can establish. Reuse the structure to present a finding without making an overly broad claim.
- 4
Would you advise us to make that distinction more explicit in the response letter?
This is a diplomatic way to ask for guidance on a proposed clarification. You can adapt it by replacing “that distinction” with the specific point you want to emphasize.
- 5
My remaining question is whether the editor expects a further change to the manuscript itself, or whether the revised explanation and limitation are sufficient for this round.
This frames an unresolved issue as a clear choice between two possible next steps. It is useful when you need to clarify expectations before making further revisions.
- 6
We’re not trying to win an argument with the reviewer; we want the manuscript to reflect the limits of the design and make the rationale transparent to readers.
This sentence emphasizes a constructive, reader-focused goal rather than defensiveness. Reuse its contrast to explain that a response aims to improve clarity, not merely prevail in a disagreement.
- 7
Make that targeted addition, and keep the response measured: thank the reviewer, summarize the changes, and distinguish the limitation from the point the sensitivity analyses can address.
This gives specific, balanced instructions for revising both a manuscript and its response letter. The colon introduces a practical sequence that can be adapted to other professional feedback.
- 8
Thank you for clarifying what would be most useful; it gives us a constructive way to close the gap without overstating what the evidence supports.
This closes the conversation with appreciation and a clear summary of the benefit of the guidance. Use it when acknowledging advice while affirming a commitment to careful claims.