Preparing a Persuasive Case
Emma explains why she hopes to adopt a small, well-trained dog, while Jack helps her anticipate the landlord’s concerns. They put together a practical proposal with references, training records, and clear promises about the apartment.
Dialogue10

I’ve been thinking seriously about adopting a small dog, but I don’t want to put the landlord on the spot without a solid proposal. Can you help me make the case?
Sure. First, we should figure out what he’s likely to worry about. Noise, damage, allergies, and whether the dog might be left alone for long stretches are probably at the top of the list.
That makes sense. I’m looking at an adult dog that’s already house-trained, not a puppy. I also work from home most days, so it wouldn’t be alone very often.
That’s a good start, but don’t rely on general assurances. If you can find a dog with a documented training history, include those records and offer to arrange a meet-and-greet.
I could also ask the rescue organization for a reference about the dog’s temperament and behavior in an apartment. Would that carry more weight than just describing it myself?
Definitely. A third-party reference makes your proposal more credible. You could also provide a reference from your previous landlord, if they’re willing to confirm you kept the apartment in good shape.
I’m happy to take responsibility for any damage, keep the dog leashed in shared areas, and make sure it doesn’t disturb the neighbors. Should I offer to pay for professional cleaning when I move out?
You can mention that as an option, but be careful not to promise more than you need to. A better approach is to say you’ll cover any pet-related damage or extra cleaning that’s actually necessary.
Good point. I’ll put everything into a one-page proposal: the dog’s training records, references, my work schedule, and clear commitments about supervision and the apartment.
That should help him see you’ve thought it through. We should also say you’re open to reasonable conditions, while making it clear you’ll wait for written approval before bringing the dog home.
Vocabulary7
- put the landlord on the spot
To pressure someone by asking them to make a decision unexpectedly. Here, Emma wants to prepare a proposal before discussing the dog with her landlord.
- make the case
To give reasons and evidence in support of a request or position. You can use this phrase when you want to persuade someone to agree.
- house-trained
Describes a pet that has learned to go to the bathroom in the appropriate place. It can reassure a landlord that a dog is less likely to cause problems indoors.
- carry more weight
To be more convincing or influential. A reference from a rescue organization may carry more weight than a pet owner’s own description.
- third-party reference
A recommendation or statement from someone not directly involved in the situation. It can make a proposal seem more credible and objective.
- thought it through
Carefully considered a plan, including its possible problems and consequences. This phrase is useful for showing that a decision is well prepared.
- written approval
Permission given in writing rather than just spoken. It creates a clear record of agreement.
Key Sentences7
- 1
Can you help me make the case?
A natural way to ask someone to help you present reasons for a request. You can reuse “make the case” when seeking support for a proposal or decision.
- 2
If you can find a dog with a documented training history, include those records and offer to arrange a meet-and-greet.
This sentence combines a condition with practical next steps. The pattern “If you can…, include… and offer to…” is useful when making a plan depend on something being available.
- 3
Would that carry more weight than just describing it myself?
A tactful way to compare the credibility of two kinds of evidence. Use “Would that carry more weight than…?” when asking which option would be more persuasive.
- 4
A third-party reference makes your proposal more credible.
This clearly explains how independent evidence can strengthen a request. You can replace “third-party reference” with another outside source of support.
- 5
A better approach is to say you’ll cover any pet-related damage or extra cleaning that’s actually necessary.
This offers a careful alternative without making an unlimited promise. The phrase “A better approach is to…” is useful for suggesting a practical solution.
- 6
That should help him see you’ve thought it through.
This is a conversational way to say that a plan appears carefully considered. Use “you’ve thought it through” to recognize someone’s preparation.
- 7
We should also say you’re open to reasonable conditions, while making it clear you’ll wait for written approval before bringing the dog home.
This sentence balances flexibility with a firm boundary. The structure “be open to…, while making it clear…” is useful in negotiations.