Negotiating Compensation
协商补偿方案
Grace and David discuss remedies, weighing a price reduction, replacement components, and expedited shipping against the cost and disruption of a formal dispute. They push back on each other’s proposals while looking for a practical compromise.
Grace 和 David 讨论补救方案,权衡降价、补发部件和加急运输,并考虑正式争议程序带来的成本与影响。他们对彼此的提议提出异议,同时寻求切实可行的折中方案。
对话12

David, we’ve reviewed the delivery records and inspection reports. Given the delay and the components that failed testing, a credit on the next order wouldn’t adequately address our losses.
David,我们已经审查了交货记录和检验报告。考虑到交货延误以及未通过检测的部件,下次订单抵扣货款不足以弥补我们的损失。
I understand your position, Grace, but a full refund for the defective components would overlook the fact that most of the shipment was usable. We could offer a ten-percent reduction on the affected units.
Grace,我理解你的立场,但如果把有缺陷部件的货款全部退还,就忽略了大部分货物仍可使用这一事实。我们可以对受影响的部件降价百分之十。
That doesn’t reflect the actual impact. We had to pause production while we sorted the usable components from the defective ones, and the late arrival compressed our schedule.
这个方案没有体现实际影响。我们不得不停下生产,先把可用部件和有缺陷的部件分开,而交货延误也压缩了我们的工期。
Then let’s consider replacements. We can ship the faulty components at no charge, though standard freight would put them there in about three weeks.
那我们来谈谈更换方案。我们可以免费寄出有问题的部件,不过如果走普通运输,大约三周才能送到。
Three weeks won’t work. We need expedited shipping, and the replacement units must be inspected before dispatch. Otherwise, we risk paying twice—in money and in lost production time.
三周不行。我们需要加急运输,而且替换部件必须在发货前完成检验。否则,我们可能要付出双重代价:既损失金钱,也损失生产时间。
I can authorize expedited freight, but not an additional price reduction. Covering the replacements and premium shipping already puts us beyond what I’d consider a proportionate remedy.
我可以批准加急运费,但不能再额外降价。我们承担替换部件和加急运输的费用,已经超出了我认为合理的补救范围。
The contract entitles us to remedies for late and nonconforming goods; it doesn’t limit us to replacement alone. Still, I’d rather settle this commercially than argue over every line of it.
合同赋予我们针对迟交和不符合约定货物寻求补救的权利,并未规定只能更换。不过,我还是更愿意通过商务协商解决,而不是逐条争辩。
Fair enough. What if we replace the failed components, expedite the shipment at our expense, and issue a five-percent credit against this invoice? That would recognize the disruption without reopening the entire order.
有道理。这样如何:我们更换未通过检测的部件,承担加急运费,并对这张发票给予百分之五的抵扣。这样既能体现我们对造成的影响有所补偿,也不必重新协商整笔订单。
A credit against this invoice is more useful than one tied to a future purchase. But five percent is still light, given the production interruption. Could you raise it to eight?
抵扣这张发票比抵扣未来的采购款更有用。但考虑到生产中断,百分之五还是偏低。你们能提高到百分之八吗?
Eight is difficult to approve. I could stretch to seven percent, provided the replacements pass inspection and we document this as a commercial settlement, not an admission of liability.
百分之八很难获批。如果替换部件通过检验,而且我们将此事书面记录为商业和解、而非承认责任,我可以争取到百分之七。
Seven percent, expedited freight at your expense, and inspection before dispatch would be a workable basis. I’d also need the credit and replacement schedule confirmed in writing before we close the matter.
百分之七、由你们承担加急运费,并在发货前完成检验,这些可以作为可行的基础。另外,在我们结案之前,我需要你们以书面形式确认抵扣金额和替换部件的交付计划。
That sounds reasonable. I’ll send a written proposal with those terms and a firm shipping date. If we can settle promptly, neither side has to spend time and money escalating the dispute.
听起来合理。我会发一份列明这些条款和确定发货日期的书面方案。如果我们能尽快达成和解,双方都不必再花时间和金钱把争议升级。
词汇8
- a credit on the next order下次订单抵扣货款
A reduction applied to a future purchase rather than money returned now. Here, Grace argues that this would not adequately compensate her company.
指不立即退款,而是在以后采购时抵扣相应金额。这里,Grace 认为这种做法不足以补偿她公司的损失。
- affected units受影响的部件
The individual items impacted by a problem. Use this phrase to distinguish defective items from the rest of a shipment.
指受到问题影响的单个物品。这个说法可以用来区分有缺陷的部件和货物中的其他部件。
- compressed our schedule压缩了我们的工期
Made the available time for planned work shorter. It is a tactful way to describe how a delay disrupted a project.
指原本用于计划工作的时间变少了。这是一种委婉的说法,用来描述延误如何打乱项目进度。
- at no charge免费
Without requiring the customer to pay. It is commonly used when offering a remedy or replacement.
指不要求客户付费。提出补救方案或更换物品时,经常会用到这个说法。
- expedited shipping加急运输
Faster-than-standard delivery, usually at an additional cost. Use it when timing is important and a regular delivery schedule will not work.
指比标准运输更快的配送方式,通常需要额外付费。时间很紧、普通配送赶不上时,可以使用这个说法。
- a proportionate remedy相称的补救措施
A solution considered fair in relation to the problem. It is useful in negotiations about compensation or corrective action.
指与问题的严重程度相匹配、被认为公平的解决方案。在协商补偿或纠正措施时,这个说法很有用。
- commercial settlement商业和解
An agreement reached to resolve a business disagreement. In this context, the phrase distinguishes a practical compromise from an admission of legal responsibility.
指通过协议解决商业纠纷。在这里,这个说法强调务实的折中方案,并非承认法律责任。
- a workable basis可行的基础
A set of terms that could realistically support an agreement. It signals willingness to proceed while leaving room to confirm the details.
指一组有望促成协议、在现实中可行的条款。这个说法表明愿意继续协商,同时也留出了确认细节的空间。
重点句子8
- 1
Given the delay and the components that failed testing, a credit on the next order wouldn’t adequately address our losses.
考虑到交货延误以及未通过检测的部件,下次订单抵扣货款不足以弥补我们的损失。
This sentence links specific problems to a clear position on compensation. Reuse the structure “Given [problem], [proposal] wouldn’t adequately address [impact]” to explain why an offer falls short.
这句话把具体问题和明确的补偿立场联系起来。你可以套用这个结构:“Given [problem], [proposal] wouldn’t adequately address [impact]”,说明为什么某项提议不足以解决问题。
- 2
We had to pause production while we sorted the usable components from the defective ones, and the late arrival compressed our schedule.
我们不得不停下生产,先把可用部件和有缺陷的部件分开,而交货延误也压缩了我们的工期。
This explains the practical consequences of a delivery problem, not just the defective goods themselves. Use it as a model for describing both immediate disruption and its effect on a timeline.
这句话说明了交货问题造成的实际后果,而不只是货物本身有缺陷。你可以参考这个说法,同时描述眼前的生产中断及其对进度的影响。
- 3
Otherwise, we risk paying twice—in money and in lost production time.
否则,我们可能要付出双重代价:既损失金钱,也损失生产时间。
This concise phrase emphasizes that a seemingly simple solution could create additional costs. Reuse “Otherwise, we risk [consequence]” to make a concern clear and persuasive.
这个简洁的说法强调,看似简单的解决方案可能带来额外成本。你可以套用“Otherwise, we risk [consequence]”来清楚、有说服力地表达顾虑。
- 4
Covering the replacements and premium shipping already puts us beyond what I’d consider a proportionate remedy.
承担替换部件和加急运输的费用,已经超出了我认为相称的补救范围。
This is a measured way to push back by explaining why a proposed compensation package feels excessive. You can adapt “beyond what I’d consider proportionate” to negotiate limits without sounding personal.
这是一种克制的反对方式,解释为什么你觉得对方提出的补偿方案过于宽泛。协商时可以灵活使用“beyond what I’d consider proportionate”,以商量的口吻说明你能接受的范围,而不显得是在针对个人。
- 5
Still, I’d rather settle this commercially than argue over every line of it.
不过,我还是更愿意通过商务协商解决,而不是逐条争辩。
This shows a preference for a practical agreement over a prolonged dispute. Use “I’d rather [constructive option] than [undesirable alternative]” to steer a difficult discussion toward resolution.
这句话表明,你更倾向于达成务实的协议,而不是陷入漫长的争议。可以套用“I’d rather [constructive option] than [undesirable alternative]”,引导棘手的讨论走向解决。
- 6
That would recognize the disruption without reopening the entire order.
这样既能体现我们对造成的影响有所补偿,也不必重新协商整笔订单。
This presents a compromise while setting a boundary around its scope. The pattern “recognize [concern] without [unwanted consequence]” is useful when explaining the purpose of a proposal.
这句话提出了折中方案,同时限定了方案的适用范围。在解释提议的目的时,“recognize [concern] without [unwanted consequence]”这个句式很有用。
- 7
Seven percent, expedited freight at your expense, and inspection before dispatch would be a workable basis.
百分之七、由你们承担加急运费,并在发货前完成检验,这些可以作为可行的基础。
This summarizes the key conditions of a possible agreement and signals conditional acceptance. Use “would be a workable basis” when you are ready to move forward but still need the terms confirmed.
这句话概括了可能达成协议的关键条件,并表示有条件地接受。准备继续推进、但仍需确认条款时,可以使用“would be a workable basis”。
- 8
If we can settle promptly, neither side has to spend time and money escalating the dispute.
如果我们能尽快达成和解,双方都不必再花时间和金钱把争议升级。
This highlights a shared benefit of reaching agreement quickly. Reuse “If we can [action], neither side has to [costly outcome]” to encourage cooperation without making a threat.
这句话强调了尽快达成协议对双方都有好处。你可以套用“If we can [action], neither side has to [costly outcome]”,在不带威胁意味的情况下促进合作。