Peer Review Feedback
同行評審反饋
A scholar receives and discusses constructive criticism and feedback on their manuscript from a peer reviewer, clarifying points and defending their arguments.
一位學者收到並討論同行評審員對其手稿提出的建設性批評和反饋,澄清觀點並捍衛他們的論點。
對話10

Thanks for finding the time to chat, Jack. I just received the peer review feedback on the manuscript, and I wanted to go over some of the points with you.
謝謝你抽空來聊,傑克。我剛收到手稿的同行評審反饋,想和你一起過一下其中一些要點。
Of course, Mia. Happy to help. What's the general gist? Are there any major revisions they're suggesting?
當然,米婭。很樂意幫忙。大致情況怎麼樣?他們有沒有提出任何重大修改建議?
Overall, it's pretty positive, which is a relief. They've raised a few really insightful questions, particularly regarding the methodology section. One reviewer thought our sample size might be perceived as a limitation.
總的來說,挺積極的,這讓我鬆了口氣。他們提出了一些非常有見地的問題,尤其是在方法論部分。一位審稿人認為我們的樣本量可能被視為一個侷限。
Ah, yes, I anticipated that might come up. Our rationale for the sample size was laid out in the initial proposal. Perhaps we need to reinforce that argument more explicitly in the manuscript itself.
啊,是的,我預料到這可能會出現。我們對樣本量的理由在最初的提案中已經闡明瞭。也許我們需要在手稿中更明確地強化這個論點。
Exactly. I was thinking we could add a paragraph or two directly addressing that. And another point, they suggested clarifying the implications of our findings for policy-making. They felt we were a bit vague there.
沒錯。我正想我們可以直接加上一兩段來解決這個問題。另外一點,他們建議我們澄清研究結果對政策制定的影響。他們覺得我們在那方面有點模糊。
That's a fair point. We focused more on the theoretical contributions. We can definitely expand on the practical applications without overstating our claims. We just need to articulate it more clearly.
這個觀點很中肯。我們之前更側重於理論貢獻。我們絕對可以在不誇大結論的情況下,擴充套件實際應用部分。我們只需要更清晰地闡述它。
I agree. So, for the sample size, I'll draft some revised text, and for the policy implications, maybe we can brainstorm a few specific examples that link directly to our data.
我同意。那麼,關於樣本量,我來起草一些修改後的文字;至於政策影響,也許我們可以集思廣益一下,想出幾個直接與我們的資料相關的具體例子。
Sounds like a solid plan. Is there anything else that caught your eye that we should discuss now?
聽起來是個不錯的計劃。還有沒有其他你注意到的我們現在應該討論的事情?
Not right now. These two seem to be the most substantive. The rest are minor edits, typos, and formatting issues which I can handle fairly easily. Thanks again for your insights!
目前沒有了。這兩點看起來是最實質性的。其餘的都是一些小修改、錯別字和格式問題,我能很輕鬆地處理。再次感謝你的見解!
Anytime, Mia. Let me know if you want me to take a look at your revisions once you've drafted them. We'll get this manuscript ready for resubmission.
隨時都可以,米婭。等你起草完修改稿,如果需要我看一下的話,告訴我。我們會把這份手稿準備好重新提交的。
詞彙8
- peer review同行評審
A process where experts check and give feedback on academic work before publication. Useful in scholarly discussions to refer to evaluation by colleagues.
專家在學術成果發表前對其進行審查並提供反饋的過程。在學術討論中,這個詞常用來指同行對研究成果的評估。
- manuscript手稿
A written document, like an article or book, prepared for publication. Commonly used in academic contexts to mean a draft paper.
準備出版的書面文稿,例如文章或書籍。在學術語境中,通常指尚未發表的論文初稿。
- feedback反饋
Comments or advice given to improve something. In academic settings, it often means constructive criticism from reviewers.
為了改進某件事而提出的意見或建議。在學術環境中,通常指審稿人提出的建設性批評。
- revisions修改
Changes or updates made to a document based on suggestions. Practical for discussing edits in writing or research.
根據建議對文稿所做的改動或更新。討論寫作或研究中的編輯修改時很實用。
- methodology方法論
The methods and techniques used in research or study. Important in academic talks to explain how data was collected.
研究或學習中採用的方法和技術。在學術討論中,這個詞常用於說明如何收集資料。
- sample size樣本量
The number of people or items studied in research. Key in discussions about study limitations or reliability.
研究中調查的人數或研究物件的數量。在討論研究侷限或可靠性時很重要。
- implications影響
Possible effects or consequences of findings. Useful when discussing how research affects real-world applications like policy.
研究發現可能產生的作用或後果。討論研究如何影響政策等現實應用時很有用。
- brainstorm集思廣益
To generate ideas together in a group. A common verb in collaborative academic or work settings for creative problem-solving.
大家一起提出想法。在學術合作或工作場合中,這是解決問題時常用的表達。
關鍵句7
- 1
Thanks for finding the time to chat.
謝謝你抽空來聊。
A polite way to thank someone for making time to talk. Useful for starting professional conversations; 'finding the time' is an idiom meaning making an effort to be available.
禮貌地感謝對方抽出時間交談。適合用來開啟工作交流;“finding the time”是一個習語,意思是設法抽出時間。
- 2
What's the general gist?
大致情況怎麼樣?
Asking for the main idea or summary. 'Gist' is informal for the essence of something; great for quickly understanding overviews in discussions.
詢問主要內容或概要。“gist”是比較口語的說法,指某件事的核心意思,適合在討論中快速瞭解概況。
- 3
Overall, it's pretty positive, which is a relief.
總的來說,情況挺積極的,這讓我鬆了口氣。
Summarizing a situation as generally good, with 'which is a relief' adding emotion. The relative clause explains why; useful for giving balanced feedback.
先概括情況總體不錯,再用“which is a relief”表達如釋重負的心情。後面的關係從句說明了原因,適合用來給出較為平衡的反饋。
- 4
I anticipated that might come up.
我預料到這個問題可能會被提出來。
Meaning 'I expected that issue to be mentioned.' 'Anticipate' shows foresight; helpful in debates to show preparation.
意思是“我原本就預計有人會提到這個問題”。“Anticipate”表示預先想到或預料到,在討論中可以用來體現自己有所準備。
- 5
We can definitely expand on the practical applications without overstating our claims.
我們完全可以進一步闡述實際應用,同時避免誇大我們的論斷。
Suggesting to add details on real-world uses while avoiding exaggeration. 'Expand on' means to develop more; useful for academic revisions to balance theory and practice.
建議補充研究在現實中的用途,同時避免誇大結論。“Expand on”意思是進一步闡述。在學術修改中,這個表達有助於兼顧理論與實踐。
- 6
Sounds like a solid plan.
聽起來是個靠譜的計劃。
Agreeing that an idea is good and reliable. 'Solid' means strong; a casual way to approve plans in team discussions.
表示認可一個好而可靠的想法。“Solid”有紮實、可靠的意思,是團隊討論中比較隨意的認可方式。
- 7
Let me know if you want me to take a look at your revisions.
如果你想讓我看看修改稿,告訴我一聲。
Offering help to review changes. 'Take a look' is idiomatic for examining; polite for collaborative work, using conditional 'if' for optionality.
主動提出幫忙審閱修改內容。“Take a look”是習語,意思是檢視或審閱;“if”條件句讓這個幫助顯得禮貌,也表明對方可以自行選擇。