Answering Hard Questions
After the announcement, Mia and Jack press David on why the cuts were made, how decisions were reached, and whether more layoffs are coming. He answers what he can without making promises he cannot keep.
Dialogue11

I want to be direct about what I can and can’t answer. The reduction was driven by a sustained shortfall in projected revenue, not by a single bad quarter or one team’s performance.
When you say “sustained shortfall,” what does that mean in practice? Were there other options—like pausing hiring or reducing executive compensation—that were seriously considered first?
Yes. Leadership reviewed several cost-saving measures, including hiring limits and reductions in discretionary spending. Those steps weren’t enough to close the gap we’re facing, though, and I understand that doesn’t make the outcome feel fair.
How were the people affected selected? I’m asking because if the criteria were vague, it’s hard for the rest of us to trust that this was handled consistently.
The company assessed which work would continue, the skills needed for that work, and the structure required going forward. Managers and HR reviewed decisions against those criteria. I can’t discuss individual cases, but I can explain the framework.
I appreciate the distinction, but it still sounds abstract. Were performance ratings used? And if they were, how did you account for differences in opportunities or workloads across teams?
Performance information could be considered where relevant, but it wasn’t the sole basis for decisions. I can’t give you a formula that would capture every case; pretending there was one would be misleading.
The question everyone’s afraid to ask: are there going to be more layoffs? I know you may not have a definitive answer, but what can you tell us honestly today?
I don’t have information that another round is planned, and I won’t speculate or promise that there won’t be one. If the outlook changes, we’re responsible for communicating that promptly, not letting rumors fill the silence.
That uncertainty has consequences. People are already wondering whether to take on more work, look for other jobs, or wait for clarity. When will we hear a substantive update, even if there’s no major change?
That’s fair. I’ll share an update at our next team meeting, even if the update is that there’s nothing new to report. You deserve a reliable communication rhythm, not certainty I can’t honestly offer.
Vocabulary7
- sustained shortfall
A continuing gap between expected revenue and the amount needed. Here, it explains that the cuts were prompted by an ongoing financial problem, not one isolated event.
- discretionary spending
Spending on things that are optional rather than essential. In this context, it refers to one of the cost-saving areas leadership reviewed.
- close the gap
To reduce or eliminate a difference between two amounts or goals. You can use this phrase when discussing how a plan might address a financial shortfall or performance target.
- against those criteria
In comparison with the standards or requirements used to make a decision. This phrase is useful for explaining how choices were reviewed consistently.
- sole basis
The only reason or factor behind a decision. Use it to clarify that a decision involved several considerations, not just one.
- definitive answer
A clear, final answer that removes doubt. Here, David says he cannot give one about whether more layoffs will happen.
- fill the silence
To take the place of a lack of communication, often with speculation or rumors. It highlights why timely updates matter when people are uncertain.
Key Sentences7
- 1
I want to be direct about what I can and can’t answer.
This sets expectations honestly before a difficult discussion. Reuse it to signal that you will be transparent while acknowledging limits.
- 2
Those steps weren’t enough to close the gap we’re facing, though, and I understand that doesn’t make the outcome feel fair.
This sentence explains why earlier alternatives did not prevent the decision while recognizing its emotional impact. The structure helps pair a factual explanation with empathy.
- 3
The company assessed which work would continue, the skills needed for that work, and the structure required going forward.
This gives a concise overview of the factors behind a decision. You can reuse the pattern “assessed [factor], [factor], and [factor]” to describe a review framework.
- 4
I can’t give you a formula that would capture every case; pretending there was one would be misleading.
This explains why a simple rule would not accurately represent a complex process. The phrasing is useful when setting limits without sounding evasive.
- 5
I don’t have information that another round is planned, and I won’t speculate or promise that there won’t be one.
This carefully distinguishes what is currently known from what cannot be guaranteed. It is a useful model for answering uncertain questions without making unsupported promises.
- 6
If the outlook changes, we’re responsible for communicating that promptly, not letting rumors fill the silence.
This acknowledges the responsibility to communicate when circumstances change. The contrast between prompt updates and rumors makes the commitment clear.
- 7
You deserve a reliable communication rhythm, not certainty I can’t honestly offer.
This recognizes what the audience can reasonably expect while maintaining an honest boundary. Reuse the contrast “You deserve [realistic commitment], not [something you cannot promise].”