Drafting the Response Letter

起草回覆信

The coauthors draft a point-by-point response letter, linking every change to a specific reviewer comment. They refine the wording so that they acknowledge valid limitations without overstating what the new analyses prove.

合著者們逐條起草回覆信,將每項修改與具體的審稿意見對應起來。他們反覆斟酌措辭,既承認合理的侷限,也不過度解讀新增分析所能證明的內容。

對話12

Drafting the Response Letter
Grace
Grace

Let’s work through the response letter point by point. For each comment, we should quote or summarize the concern, state what we changed, and direct the reviewer to the relevant section.

我們逐條處理這封回覆信吧。對於每條意見,我們都應該引用或概述問題,說明做了哪些修改,並指出稿件中相關的部分。

Emma
Emma

For the concern about the sampling strategy, we added a sensitivity analysis. Can we say it confirms that our findings are robust? That sounds stronger and more reassuring.

針對抽樣策略方面的擔憂,我們增加了一項敏感性分析。我們能不能說這證實了研究結果具有穩健性?這樣聽起來更有說服力,也更令人安心。

Mia
Mia

I’d avoid “confirms.” The analysis shows that the main pattern persists under alternative specifications, but it doesn’t eliminate every limitation or establish that our sample is fully representative.

我會避免使用“證實”這個詞。分析結果表明,在採用其他設定時,主要趨勢依然存在;但它並不能消除所有侷限,也不能證明我們的樣本完全具有代表性。

Grace
Grace

Agreed. Let’s acknowledge the reviewer’s valid point first, then explain the additional analysis without implying that it settles the broader question of generalizability.

同意。我們先承認審稿人提出了合理的問題,再說明新增分析的結果,同時不要暗示它解決了關於普遍適用性的更廣泛問題。

Emma
Emma

How about: “We agree that the original manuscript did not sufficiently clarify the sampling rationale. We have expanded that explanation and added a sensitivity analysis.”

這樣寫怎麼樣:“我們同意,原稿未能充分說明抽樣依據。我們已補充相關解釋,並增加了一項敏感性分析。”

Mia
Mia

That’s a good opening. We could add that the primary estimates remain substantively similar across the alternative specifications, while noting that the revised text now makes the sampling constraints explicit.

這個開頭很好。我們可以補充說明,在其他設定下,主要估計結果在實質上仍然相近,同時指出修訂後的文字已明確說明抽樣方面的限制。

Grace
Grace

Let’s be precise about where the changes appear: the sampling rationale is in the Methods section, and the sensitivity results are in the new paragraph in the Results section.

我們要準確指出修改的位置:抽樣依據寫在“方法”部分,敏感性分析的結果則放在“結果”部分新增的段落中。

Emma
Emma

I’ve drafted that. For the request to clarify the exclusion criteria, should we simply say we’ve added the details, or explain why those cases were excluded?

我已經起草好了。關於補充排除標準的要求,我們只需說已經新增了具體資訊,還是也應該解釋排除這些案例的原因?

Mia
Mia

Both. A bare statement that we revised the text may sound perfunctory. Let’s briefly explain the rationale and point to the exact subsection, without repeating the entire Methods section in the letter.

兩者都要。只說我們修改了文字,聽起來可能流於形式。我們簡要說明理由,並指出具體的小節即可,不必在回覆信中重複整段“方法”內容。

Grace
Grace

And let’s keep the tone measured. We can say, “We appreciate the reviewer’s suggestion; the clarification has improved the manuscript,” rather than sounding as though we’re conceding a flaw we don’t believe exists.

我們也要注意語氣,保持得體。可以寫:“感謝審稿人的建議;這項說明完善了稿件。”這樣既不會顯得我們承認了自己並不認為存在的問題。

Emma
Emma

Understood. I’ll check that every response identifies the change and its location, and that we haven’t claimed more than the revisions actually support.

明白了。我會檢查每條回覆是否都指出了修改內容及其位置,也會確認我們沒有做出超出這些修改實際所能支援的主張。

Mia
Mia

Good. Once we’ve checked the page and line references against the revised manuscript, we can do one final read for consistency and send the letter to the editor.

很好。等我們核對完頁碼和行號,確保與修訂稿一致後,就可以最後通讀一遍,檢查前後是否一致,然後把回覆信發給編輯。

詞彙7

  • point by point逐條

    One item at a time, in an organized sequence. Here, it means addressing each reviewer comment separately.

    按有條理的順序逐項處理。這裡指分別回應每一條審稿意見。

  • sensitivity analysis敏感性分析

    An analysis that tests whether results change under different assumptions or specifications. It can show how stable findings are, but it does not remove every limitation.

    透過改變假設或模型設定來檢驗結果是否會發生變化的分析。它可以顯示研究結果有多穩定,但無法消除所有侷限。

  • alternative specifications其他設定

    Different ways of setting up or modeling an analysis. Researchers compare them to see whether the main results remain similar.

    對分析進行設定或建模的不同方式。研究者會比較這些方式,看看主要結果是否依然相近。

  • generalizability普遍適用性

    The extent to which findings apply beyond the specific people or cases studied. A study’s sampling constraints may limit its generalizability.

    研究結果適用於所研究的特定人群或案例以外的範圍。研究抽樣方面的限制可能會影響結果的普遍適用性。

  • perfunctory敷衍的

    Done in a way that feels brief or routine, without enough thought or detail. A response that merely says text was revised may sound perfunctory.

    做得簡略或流於形式,缺少足夠的思考或細節。回覆如果只是說修改了文字,聽起來可能會顯得敷衍。

  • measured審慎的

    Careful and moderate in tone, avoiding extreme claims. In a response letter, measured wording can acknowledge a concern without overstating agreement.

    語氣謹慎、適度,避擴音出過於極端的主張。在回覆信中,審慎的措辭可以承認對方的關切,又不表示過度認同。

  • substantively similar實質上相近

    Similar in the important respects, even if details differ. Researchers can use this phrase to describe results that remain broadly consistent across analyses.

    即使細節有所不同,重要方面仍然相近。研究者可以用這個短語來形容不同分析中的結果總體上保持一致。

關鍵句8

  1. 1

    For each comment, we should quote or summarize the concern, state what we changed, and direct the reviewer to the relevant section.

    對於每條意見,我們都應該引用或概述問題,說明做了哪些修改,並指出稿件中相關的部分。

    This gives a clear structure for responding to feedback. Reuse it to explain how you will address comments systematically and show where revisions appear.

    這為回應反饋提供了清晰的結構。你可以借用這個句式,說明自己將如何系統地處理各條意見,並指出修改內容所在的位置。

  2. 2

    The analysis shows that the main pattern persists under alternative specifications, but it doesn’t eliminate every limitation or establish that our sample is fully representative.

    分析結果表明,在其他設定下,主要趨勢依然存在;但它並不能消除所有侷限,也不能證明我們的樣本完全具有代表性。

    This sentence describes evidence while carefully stating what it cannot prove. Reuse the pattern “shows that…, but it doesn’t…” to make a balanced claim.

    這句話陳述了證據,同時謹慎說明了它無法證明什麼。你可以借用 “shows that…, but it doesn’t…” 這個句式,提出平衡的主張。

  3. 3

    Let’s acknowledge the reviewer’s valid point first, then explain the additional analysis without implying that it settles the broader question of generalizability.

    我們先承認審稿人提出了合理的問題,再說明新增分析的結果,同時不要暗示它解決了關於普遍適用性的更廣泛問題。

    This is useful when responding respectfully without claiming that one revision resolves a larger issue. Reuse it to sequence an acknowledgment and a qualified explanation.

    當你想要禮貌回應,又不想聲稱某一項修改解決了更大的問題時,這種表達很有用。你可以借用這種結構,先表示認同,再給出有所保留的說明。

  4. 4

    We agree that the original manuscript did not sufficiently clarify the sampling rationale.

    我們同意,原稿未能充分說明抽樣依據。

    This directly acknowledges a specific shortcoming in the earlier version. Reuse “did not sufficiently clarify” to describe a gap without suggesting that the underlying research was invalid.

    這句話直接承認了先前版本中的一處具體不足。你可以借用 “did not sufficiently clarify” 來描述某處交代不足,同時不暗示研究本身無效。

  5. 5

    The primary estimates remain substantively similar across the alternative specifications, while noting that the revised text now makes the sampling constraints explicit.

    在其他設定下,主要估計結果在實質上仍然相近;同時,修訂後的文字也明確說明了抽樣方面的限制。

    This combines a concise report of results with a clear acknowledgment of limitations. Reuse this kind of contrast to present evidence and constraints together.

    這句話簡潔地報告了結果,也明確承認了研究的侷限。你可以借用這種對比結構,把證據和限制放在一起說明。

  6. 6

    A bare statement that we revised the text may sound perfunctory.

    只說我們修改了文字,聽起來可能會顯得敷衍。

    This sentence explains why a response should include more than a claim that changes were made. Reuse it when asking someone to add a rationale or specific details.

    這句話說明了為什麼回覆不應只聲稱做了修改。你可以在請對方補充理由或具體細節時使用這種表達。

  7. 7

    I’ll check that every response identifies the change and its location, and that we haven’t claimed more than the revisions actually support.

    我會檢查每條回覆是否都指出了修改內容及其位置,也會確認我們沒有做出超出這些修改實際所能支援的主張。

    This is a useful final quality-control check for a response letter. Reuse it to ensure each reply is traceable and its claims are supported.

    這是檢查回覆信質量時很有用的最後一步。你可以借用它來確認每條回覆都能追溯到具體修改,而且其中的主張都有依據。

  8. 8

    Once we’ve checked the page and line references against the revised manuscript, we can do one final read for consistency and send the letter to the editor.

    等我們核對完頁碼和行號,確保與修訂稿一致後,就可以最後通讀一遍,檢查前後是否一致,然後把回覆信發給編輯。

    This sentence lays out practical final steps before submission. Reuse its structure to describe what must be verified before a document is sent.

    這句話列出了提交前切實可行的最後幾項工作。你可以借用這種結構,說明傳送檔案前需要核實哪些內容。

喜歡《English Dialogue》嗎?

在 Microsoft Store 留下簡短評分,能幫助其他學習者找到這款應用程式。