Deciding What to Rebut
決定反駁哪些意見
The coauthors decide which points to accept, which to explain more clearly, and which to rebut with evidence. Grace reminds them that a persuasive response should remain respectful even when the reviewer’s conclusion is questionable.
合著者們決定哪些意見應接受,哪些需要進一步解釋,以及哪些應以證據反駁。Grace提醒大家,即使審稿人的結論值得質疑,回應也應保持尊重和說服力。
對話11

Let’s take the comments one at a time. I’ve marked the sampling criticism as something we may need to rebut, but I don’t want us to dismiss it before we’ve checked the evidence.
我們逐條看這些意見吧。我把關於抽樣的批評標成了可能需要反駁的部分,但在核對證據之前,我不想貿然否定它。
Agreed. The reviewer says our sample isn’t representative, but our aim was to estimate associations within this defined population, not to make population-wide prevalence claims.
同意。審稿人說我們的樣本不具代表性,但我們的目標是估計這個特定人群內部的關聯,而不是推斷整個總體的患病率。
That distinction is important, but let’s ask whether the manuscript makes it clear enough. If a careful reader could reasonably infer a broader claim, we should own that ambiguity.
這個區別很重要,但我們得看看稿子有沒有把它說清楚。如果細心的讀者確實可能把我們的結論理解得更寬泛,那我們就該承認表述存在歧義。
I checked the discussion. We do say the findings may inform similar settings, but we don’t explicitly limit that statement to settings with comparable recruitment and eligibility criteria.
我檢查了討論部分。我們確實說過這些發現可能適用於類似環境,但沒有明確限定為招募方式和納入標準相近的環境。
Then we should revise that sentence and acknowledge the limits to generalizability. That’s a fair point to accept, even if the reviewer’s claim that the design is fundamentally flawed goes too far.
那我們應該修改那句話,並承認研究結果的普遍適用性有限。這一點值得接受,儘管審稿人稱研究設計存在根本缺陷,未免說得太重。
Exactly. We can accept the valid concern without conceding a conclusion the data don’t support. A response letter isn’t a courtroom, and nobody gets extra credit for sounding combative.
正是如此。我們可以接受合理的擔憂,卻不必認同資料無法支援的結論。回覆信不是法庭,語氣咄咄逼人也不會讓我們多得分。
For the point about selection bias, we can explain that recruitment was consecutive at the participating clinics, then state plainly that people who never sought care weren’t represented.
關於選擇偏倚,我們可以說明參與診所採用的是連續招募,同時坦率指出,從未就醫的人群並未納入樣本。
We should also cite the enrollment flow and compare participants with the clinic’s eligible-patient profile, if those figures are available. That gives us something concrete, rather than just asserting the sample was appropriate.
如果能拿到相關資料,我們還應該引用入組流程,並將參與者與診所符合條件的患者構成進行比較。這樣就有具體依據,而不只是聲稱樣本合適。
I can verify those numbers. If the comparison is incomplete, we’ll say so; I’d rather disclose a gap than imply we conducted an analysis we didn’t do.
我可以核實這些資料。如果比較不完整,我們就如實說明;我寧願坦承缺口,也不想讓人誤以為我們做過實際上並未進行的分析。
Good. Let’s separate the response into two parts: clarify the study’s intended scope, and acknowledge who may be missing from the sample. Then we can rebut the claim of fundamental invalidity with specific design details.
很好。我們把回覆分成兩部分:澄清研究預期適用的範圍,並承認哪些人群可能未被納入樣本。隨後再用具體的設計細節反駁研究存在根本缺陷的說法。
And let’s avoid saying the reviewer misunderstood us. We can write, “We appreciate this concern and have revised the text to clarify…” That corrects the record without making the exchange personal.
我們也別說審稿人誤解了我們。可以寫:“感謝您提出這一問題,我們已修改文稿以進一步澄清……”這樣既能說明情況,也不會把討論變成針對個人。
詞彙6
- representative有代表性的
In this context, a representative sample reflects the wider population the researchers want to draw conclusions about.
在這裡,有代表性的樣本能夠反映研究人員希望據此得出結論的更廣泛人群。
- generalizability普遍適用性
This means how well findings can apply beyond the people or settings included in a study. Use it when discussing the limits of a study’s conclusions.
這個詞指研究發現能在多大程度上適用於研究中未涉及的人群或環境。討論研究結論的侷限時,可以用這個詞。
- selection bias選擇偏倚
This is distortion that occurs when the people included in a study differ systematically from those who are not included.
當納入研究的人群與未納入的人群存在系統性差異時,就會產生這種偏差。
- consecutive連續的
Here, consecutive recruitment means inviting eligible patients in sequence as they attend the clinics, rather than selecting them selectively.
在這裡,連續招募是指按照先後順序邀請前來診所、符合條件的患者,而不是有選擇地挑選患者。
- enrollment flow入組流程
This refers to the sequence and number of people screened, eligible, enrolled, or excluded from a study. It can provide concrete evidence about how the sample was formed.
這個詞指研究中接受篩查、符合條件、入組或被排除的人數及其流程。它能為樣本是如何形成的提供具體依據。
- rebut反駁
To rebut a claim is to challenge it with reasons or evidence. The dialogue emphasizes doing this respectfully rather than dismissing the reviewer.
反駁一項主張,就是用理由或證據對它提出質疑。對話強調,反駁時要保持尊重,而不是一味否定審稿人。
關鍵句7
- 1
If a careful reader could reasonably infer a broader claim, we should own that ambiguity.
如果細心的讀者有理由將其理解為更寬泛的主張,我們就應該承認這種表述存在歧義。
This sentence shows how to take responsibility for unclear writing without accepting a criticism wholesale. Reuse the pattern “If a reader could reasonably infer…, we should…” when identifying a possible misunderstanding.
這句話展示瞭如何為表述不清承擔責任,同時又不全盤接受批評。指出可能存在誤解時,可以套用“如果讀者有理由認為……,我們就應該……”這個句式。
- 2
Then we should revise that sentence and acknowledge the limits to generalizability.
那麼我們應該修改那句話,並承認研究結果的普遍適用性有限。
This is a concise way to propose a specific revision and state what limitation it addresses. Adapt it by naming the passage to revise and the relevant limitation.
這是一種簡潔的說法,既提出了具體的修改建議,也說明了修改針對什麼侷限。你可以指出需要修改的內容和相關侷限,仿照這個句式來表達。
- 3
We can accept the valid concern without conceding a conclusion the data don’t support.
我們可以接受合理的擔憂,但不必認同資料無法支援的結論。
This sentence carefully separates an appropriate concession from a claim that lacks evidence. It is useful when responding firmly but professionally to criticism.
這句話謹慎地區分了應當接受的讓步和缺乏證據支援的主張。在回應批評時,既堅定又專業,這種說法很有用。
- 4
A response letter isn’t a courtroom, and nobody gets extra credit for sounding combative.
回覆信不是法庭,語氣咄咄逼人也不會讓我們多得分。
This memorable sentence reminds coauthors that the goal is a constructive scholarly exchange, not a personal contest. Use its underlying principle to keep responses measured and respectful.
這句令人印象深刻的話提醒合著者,目標是進行建設性的學術交流,而不是爭勝負。記住它的原則,讓回覆保持克制和尊重。
- 5
If the comparison is incomplete, we’ll say so; I’d rather disclose a gap than imply we conducted an analysis we didn’t do.
如果比較不完整,我們就如實說明;我寧願坦承缺口,也不想讓人以為我們做過實際上並未進行的分析。
This sentence models transparency about missing or incomplete evidence. Reuse the contrast between disclosing a limitation and implying unsupported work.
這句話示範瞭如何坦誠說明證據缺失或不完整。你可以借鑑其中的對比:坦承侷限,而不是暗示自己做過缺乏依據的工作。
- 6
Let’s separate the response into two parts: clarify the study’s intended scope, and acknowledge who may be missing from the sample.
我們把回覆分成兩部分:澄清研究預期適用的範圍,並承認哪些人群可能未被納入樣本。
This sentence turns a complicated criticism into two manageable response tasks. The structure “separate this into two parts” is useful for organizing revisions and response letters.
這句話把複雜的批評拆成了兩項容易處理的回應任務。“把這件事分成兩部分”這種結構有助於安排修改工作和撰寫回覆信。
- 7
We can write, “We appreciate this concern and have revised the text to clarify…”
我們可以寫:“感謝您提出這一問題,我們已修改文稿以進一步澄清……”
This provides a polite opening for explaining a revision without making the exchange personal. Complete the sentence by briefly stating what the revised text now clarifies.
這句話提供了一種禮貌的開場方式,可以說明所做的修改,同時避免把交流變成針對個人。接下來簡要說明修改後的文稿澄清了什麼即可。