Hearing the Second Employee’s Side
傾聽第二位員工的說法
Mia hears Jack’s account of the same dispute and asks him to distinguish what he observed from what he inferred. She listens for the pressures and concerns behind his choices.
米婭傾聽傑克對同一場矛盾的講述,並請他區分親眼所見與個人推斷。她留意促使他採取相應做法的壓力和顧慮。
對話12

Thanks for meeting with me, Jack. I’ve heard Leo’s account, and now I want to understand yours without jumping to conclusions. Please take me through what happened from your perspective.
謝謝你來和我談,傑克。我已經聽過利奧的說法,現在想了解你的看法,不急著下結論。請從你的角度說說事情的經過。
The handoff was due Friday afternoon. I didn’t receive the revised figures until late that day, so I sent the report using the numbers I had. I thought I was working with the latest version.
交接原定在週五下午。我直到那天很晚才收到修訂後的資料,所以就用手頭的資料發出了報告。我以為那已經是最新版本。
Let’s separate what you directly observed from what you concluded. You received the figures late—that’s something you know. What led you to believe the earlier numbers were still approved?
我們先把你親眼看到的情況和你的判斷區分開。你確實是很晚才收到資料,這點你知道。是什麼讓你認為之前的資料仍然獲得了批准?
The shared folder still showed my file as the final draft, and nobody had flagged it as outdated. I inferred that the revisions were still being checked, not that I was expected to replace the figures immediately.
共享資料夾裡仍把我的檔案標為最終草稿,也沒人提醒我它已經過時。我據此推斷,修訂內容還在核對中,而不是需要我立刻替換資料。
Did Leo tell you directly that the figures had changed, or was the update available somewhere without a clear handoff? I’m asking because those are different communication problems.
利奧有沒有直接告訴你資料已經變了?還是更新內容雖然放在某處,卻沒有明確交接?我這樣問,是因為這涉及不同的溝通問題。
He sent a message saying he’d updated the analysis, but he didn’t say the report was waiting on it. I can see how I should have checked; at the time, I was covering two deadlines and assumed the folder would be current.
他發訊息說自己更新了分析,但沒說報告正等著這次更新。我現在明白自己本該核實一下;當時我同時趕兩個截止日期,就以為資料夾裡的內容會是最新的。
What pressure were you under that afternoon, beyond the deadlines? I want to understand what shaped your decision, not use the pressure to excuse any impact it may have had.
那天下午,除了截止日期之外,你還承受著什麼壓力?我想了解是什麼影響了你的決定,而不是拿壓力來開脫可能造成的影響。
I was worried the client would receive nothing if I held the report for clarification. I also felt I was being asked to move quickly without clear ownership of the final figures, so I made the call myself.
我擔心如果為了確認情況而扣下報告,客戶就什麼也收不到。我也覺得大家要求我儘快推進,卻沒有說清楚誰負責最終資料,所以我就自己做了決定。
When you say “clear ownership,” do you mean knowing who approves the figures, who updates the shared file, or both? And what would have helped you raise the uncertainty sooner?
你說的“明確責任”具體是指知道誰來批准資料、誰來更新共享檔案,還是兩者都有?另外,什麼做法能幫助你更早提出疑問?
Both, ideally. A named owner for the final numbers and a brief note saying whether the report should wait would have helped. I could also have called Leo instead of treating silence as confirmation.
最好兩方面都明確。指定一個人負責最終資料,再簡短說明報告是否應該暫緩,都會有所幫助。我也可以直接打電話問利奧,而不是把沒人回覆當作確認。
That distinction is useful. I’ll carry forward both the process gap you’ve identified and your recognition that checking directly was an option. Is there anything about the impact on your work that you want me to understand?
這個區分很有幫助。我會把你指出的流程漏洞,以及你意識到自己本可以直接核實這兩點都記下來。對於這件事對你工作的影響,還有什麼是你希望我瞭解的嗎?
I spent the next morning correcting the report and explaining the discrepancy, which was stressful. I’m willing to discuss a clearer handoff, as long as responsibility for approval and updates is shared rather than left ambiguous.
第二天上午,我花了不少時間更正報告並解釋資料差異,壓力很大。我願意討論如何讓交接更清楚,只希望審批和更新的責任能明確分擔,而不是繼續含糊不清。
詞彙8
- jumping to conclusions妄下結論
Making a judgment before you have enough information. Here, Mia signals that she wants to hear Jack’s perspective before deciding what happened.
指在掌握足夠資訊之前就作出判斷。這裡,米婭表示她想先聽聽傑克的看法,再判斷事情的經過。
- from your perspective從你的角度來看
From the way you experienced or understood a situation. Use this phrase to invite someone to explain their side.
指根據你對某個情況的經歷或理解。可以用這個短語請對方講講自己的看法。
- separate what you directly observed from what you concluded區分親眼所見和個人判斷
Distinguish facts you witnessed from interpretations you formed. This is useful when clarifying disagreements or investigating an incident.
把親眼看到的事實和自己形成的解讀區分開來。在澄清分歧或調查事件時,這樣做很有幫助。
- flagged it as outdated標記為過時
Marked or identified something as no longer current. You can use “flag” as a verb when asking someone to draw attention to a problem or change.
標明某項內容已不再是最新的。你也可以把 “flag” 當動詞用,表示提醒別人注意某個問題或變化。
- clear handoff明確交接
An explicit transfer of information or responsibility from one person to another. In a workplace, a clear handoff helps prevent missed updates and unclear ownership.
指一個人向另一個人清楚地移交資訊或責任。在工作中,明確交接有助於避免遺漏更新或責任歸屬不清。
- treating silence as confirmation把沉默當作確認
Assuming that no response means agreement or approval. The phrase is useful for describing a risky communication assumption.
指認為沒有回覆就代表對方同意或批准。這個短語適合用來描述一種有風險的溝通假設。
- process gap流程漏洞
A missing or unclear step in a procedure. Here, it refers to a weakness in how the team manages and communicates revised figures.
指流程中缺失或不明確的步驟。這裡指團隊管理和溝通修訂後資料的方式存在不足。
- left ambiguous沒有明確說明
Not clearly defined or explained. Use this phrase when responsibility, expectations, or instructions have not been made clear.
指沒有清楚地界定或解釋。當責任、預期或指示不夠明確時,可以用這個短語。
關鍵句7
- 1
I’ve heard Leo’s account, and now I want to understand yours without jumping to conclusions.
我已經聽過利奧的說法,現在想了解你的看法,不急著下結論。
This is a tactful way to show that you are listening to both sides before forming an opinion. Reuse it in a sensitive discussion by replacing the names and the issue.
這是一種委婉的說法,表明你會先聽取雙方的意見,再形成看法。在敏感的談話中,可以替換人名和事情來使用這個句型。
- 2
Let’s separate what you directly observed from what you concluded.
我們先把你親眼看到的情況和你的判斷區分開。
This sentence helps distinguish verifiable facts from interpretations. It is useful in conflict resolution, interviews, and problem-solving conversations.
這句話有助於區分可以核實的事實和個人解讀。它適用於解決衝突、訪談和討論問題。
- 3
I’m asking because those are different communication problems.
我這樣問,是因為這涉及不同的溝通問題。
This explains why you are asking a clarifying question without sounding accusatory. Use it when different versions of an event could point to different underlying issues.
這句話可以解釋你為什麼提出澄清問題,同時避免聽起來像是在指責對方。當同一件事的不同說法可能指向不同的根本問題時,可以這樣說。
- 4
I want to understand what shaped your decision, not use the pressure to excuse any impact it may have had.
我想了解是什麼影響了你的決定,而不是拿壓力來開脫可能造成的影響。
This acknowledges someone’s circumstances while making clear that the effects of their actions still matter. It is useful when balancing empathy with accountability.
這句話既體諒對方的處境,也明確表示其行為造成的影響仍然重要。在表達同理心的同時要求對方承擔責任時,這樣說很有用。
- 5
I could also have called Leo instead of treating silence as confirmation.
我也可以直接打電話問利奧,而不是把沒人回覆當作確認。
This sentence recognizes a specific alternative action and takes responsibility without overstating blame. Reuse the structure “I could have [action] instead of [assumption].”
這句話指出了一個具體的替代做法,也是在承擔責任,但沒有過分歸咎於自己。可以套用這個句型:“I could have [action] instead of [assumption].”(我本可以[採取某個行動],而不是[作出某種假設]。)
- 6
I’ll carry forward both the process gap you’ve identified and your recognition that checking directly was an option.
我會把你指出的流程漏洞,以及你意識到自己本可以直接核實這兩點都記下來。
This summarizes two sides of an account: a system issue and an individual choice. It is useful for showing that you have heard a nuanced perspective.
這句話總結了講述中的兩個方面:制度流程的問題和個人的選擇。用它可以表明你聽到了對方較為全面、細緻的看法。
- 7
I’m willing to discuss a clearer handoff, as long as responsibility for approval and updates is shared rather than left ambiguous.
我願意討論如何讓交接更清楚,只希望審批和更新的責任能明確分擔,而不是繼續含糊不清。
This expresses willingness to collaborate while setting a clear condition. Use “I’m willing to…, as long as…” to make a constructive but firm proposal.
這句話表達了合作的意願,同時也提出了明確的條件。可以用 “I’m willing to…, as long as…”(我願意……,只要……)來提出建設性但立場堅定的建議。