Back to Situations
Insurance Claims

Negotiating a Settlement Offer

The insurance company makes an offer for the claim settlement, and the policyholder either accepts it or attempts to negotiate a higher amount, discussing the reasons for their request.

Dialogue

Listen and follow along with the conversation

1
insurance_adjuster (Male)
Good morning, Ms. Chen. I'm calling to discuss the settlement offer for your recent claim regarding the storm damage to your roof. We've assessed the damages and are proposing a settlement of $8,500.
2
policyholder (Female)
Good morning. Thank you for the update. While I appreciate the prompt assessment, $8,500 seems a bit low. My contractor’s estimate for the repairs came in at $11,000, and that includes the cost of quality materials to match the existing roof.
3
insurance_adjuster (Male)
I understand your concern. Our offer is based on the fair market value for repairs in your area using standard materials. Could you tell me more about what your contractor's estimate covers that exceeds our assessment?
4
policyholder (Female)
Certainly. Their estimate accounts for the specific type of shingles needed to match the existing ones, which are a higher grade than standard. It also includes disposal fees for the damaged materials, and a more comprehensive clean-up, which wasn't clearly itemized in your report.
5
insurance_adjuster (Male)
I see. Matching existing materials can indeed add to the cost. Regarding the disposal fees and comprehensive clean-up, those are typically factored into the overall labor cost, but I can certainly re-evaluate that line item. Would you be able to send over your contractor's detailed estimate for us to review?
6
policyholder (Female)
Yes, I can email it to you right after this call. I really think a revised offer closer to $10,500 would be more fair, considering the details I’ve provided.
7
insurance_adjuster (Male)
Okay, Ms. Chen. Once we receive and review your contractor's detailed estimate, especially noting the higher-grade shingle cost and comprehensive clean-up, we will reassess our offer. Please allow us a couple of business days for this review. We'll be in touch.
8
policyholder (Female)
That sounds reasonable. I'll send that email right away. Thank you for your flexibility and for taking my concerns into consideration.

Vocabulary

Essential words and phrases from the dialogue

settlement

A settlement is an agreement to end a dispute by paying money, often used in insurance to resolve claims.

claim

A claim is a formal request for payment from an insurance company after damage or loss occurs.

assess

To assess means to evaluate or examine something carefully, like damages, to determine its value or extent.

estimate

An estimate is an approximate calculation of the cost or amount needed for repairs or work.

contractor

A contractor is a person or company hired to do specific work, like home repairs.

repairs

Repairs are actions to fix something that is damaged or broken.

fair market value

Fair market value is the reasonable price for something based on what similar items cost in the local area.

re-evaluate

To re-evaluate means to assess or review something again, often after new information is provided.

Key Sentences

Important phrases to remember and practice

We've assessed the damages and are proposing a settlement of $8,500.

This sentence uses present perfect 'we've assessed' to show a completed action with current relevance, and 'proposing' to suggest an offer; useful for explaining decisions in business or insurance talks.

While I appreciate the prompt assessment, $8,500 seems a bit low.

This polite negotiation sentence starts with 'while' to acknowledge positives before stating disagreement; 'seems a bit low' softens criticism, ideal for discussions where you want to negotiate without offending.

I understand your concern. Our offer is based on the fair market value for repairs in your area.

'I understand your concern' shows empathy; 'based on' explains reasoning. Useful for responding professionally in negotiations to build trust and justify positions.

Could you tell me more about what your contractor's estimate covers that exceeds our assessment?

This is a polite request for more details using 'could you tell me' for indirectness; 'exceeds' means goes beyond. Great for gathering information in conversations without being demanding.

I really think a revised offer closer to $10,500 would be more fair, considering the details I’ve provided.

'I really think' expresses strong opinion politely; 'considering' introduces reasons. This pattern helps propose alternatives in negotiations by linking to evidence.

Thank you for your flexibility and for taking my concerns into consideration.

This closing sentence uses 'thank you for' to express gratitude; 'taking into consideration' means considering carefully. Useful for ending talks positively and maintaining good relations.