Back to Situations
Patent Application Process

Drafting Patent Claims Discussion

The attorney and inventor collaborate on drafting the patent claims, defining the specific legal boundaries of the invention to ensure broad protection while avoiding existing patents.

Dialogue

Listen and follow along with the conversation

1
Attorney (Male)
Good morning, Michael. Let's dig into these patent claims for your new sustainable packaging material. I've drafted an initial set, focusing on the composition and manufacturing process.
2
Inventor (Male)
Good morning, Sarah. Thanks. I've reviewed them and overall, they look good. My main concern is ensuring we have broad enough protection. Are we covering all potential variations of the material?
3
Attorney (Male)
That's a very valid point. I've tried to use enabling language and functional limitations where possible to encompass future embodiments. For instance, instead of 'cellulose fiber,' I've used 'a plant-derived fibrous material.'
4
Inventor (Male)
That's smart. What about the biodegradability aspect? That's a key differentiator. Have we specified the degradation rate or conditions?
5
Attorney (Male)
Excellent question. I've included a claim relating to the material degrading within a certain timeframe under specific environmental conditions, but we can make it more precise if you have empirical data to support narrower ranges.
6
Inventor (Male)
Yes, we do. We have data showing degradation within 90 days in a composting facility. Can we specify that, perhaps as a dependent claim?
7
Attorney (Male)
Absolutely. That's a strong feature. We can add a dependent claim that specifies the 90-day degradation in a composting environment. It provides a concrete example without limiting the broader independent claim.
8
Inventor (Male)
Perfect. One last thing – have we run any prior art searches specifically against the structural integrity of the material when wet? That's another area where we've made significant advancements.
9
Attorney (Male)
We did an initial search, but I recommend a more targeted one for that specific feature. It's crucial we don't accidentally claim something already known. I'll arrange for that to be done immediately.
10
Inventor (Male)
Great, thanks Sarah. That gives me much more confidence in the claims.

Vocabulary

Essential words and phrases from the dialogue

patent claims

These are the legal statements in a patent that define the exact boundaries of what the invention protects. Use this term when discussing inventions and legal protection.

broad protection

This means covering a wide range of possibilities to prevent others from copying similar ideas. It's useful in legal or business talks about securing rights.

embodiments

Different ways or versions of implementing an invention. Say this when talking about variations or examples in technical discussions.

biodegradability

The ability of a material to break down naturally by bacteria or other biological means. Common in environmental or product discussions.

empirical data

Information based on observation or experiments, not theory. Use it in scientific or research contexts to refer to real evidence.

dependent claim

A patent claim that adds specific details to a main (independent) claim. It's narrower and provides extra protection; use in legal invention talks.

independent claim

The main patent claim that stands alone without referring to others. It defines the core invention; mention it when outlining patent structure.

prior art

Existing inventions or knowledge before your patent filing that can affect its approval. Essential in patent discussions to check novelty.

Key Sentences

Important phrases to remember and practice

That's a very valid point.

This sentence agrees with someone's concern and shows it's important. It's useful for professional discussions to build rapport; the structure 'That's a [adjective] [noun]' is common for polite agreement.

I've tried to use enabling language and functional limitations where possible.

Here, the speaker explains their approach to make claims broad. Useful for describing efforts in planning; note the past perfect 'I've tried' for recent actions with present relevance.

That's a key differentiator.

This highlights what makes something unique. Say it in business or product talks to emphasize advantages; 'differentiator' is a noun for something that sets apart.

Excellent question.

A polite way to acknowledge a good inquiry before answering. Common in meetings or consultations to encourage dialogue; use it to show appreciation.

We can make it more precise if you have empirical data to support narrower ranges.

This offers to refine based on evidence. Useful for collaborative work; conditional 'if' clause shows possibility, and 'narrower ranges' means more specific limits.

Absolutely. That's a strong feature.

Strong agreement followed by praise. Perfect for confirming ideas positively in discussions; 'Absolutely' is emphatic, and the period separates for clarity.

It's crucial we don't accidentally claim something already known.

Emphasizes importance of avoiding mistakes. Use in advisory contexts; 'crucial' means very important, and 'we don't accidentally' uses subjunctive for hypothetical prevention.

That gives me much more confidence in the claims.

Expresses increased trust after discussion. Helpful for ending talks positively; 'gives me confidence' is a common structure for stating how something affects feelings.