Debating What to Disclose
讨论应披露哪些信息
The team weighs the duty to inform customers promptly against the risk of issuing a misleading account before the investigation is complete. Grace pushes for clear, measured language that acknowledges uncertainty without minimizing the incident.
团队权衡尽快通知客户的责任,以及在调查完成前发布误导性说明的风险。格蕾丝主张措辞清晰、审慎,既承认不确定性,也不淡化事件的严重程度。
对话12

We need to decide what we can responsibly tell customers today. The investigation is still active, but silence has its own cost—and may look like we’re waiting for certainty we may never get.
我们得决定今天能负责任地向客户透露哪些信息。调查仍在进行,但保持沉默也有代价——看起来可能像是在等一个我们或许永远无法获得的确切结论。
Agreed. We should distinguish what’s confirmed from what remains under investigation. We know an unauthorized party accessed a system containing customer records; we don’t yet know whether those records were downloaded or misused.
同意。我们应该把已确认的事实与仍在调查的事项区分开来。我们知道未经授权的一方访问了一个存有客户记录的系统;但还不知道这些记录是否被下载或滥用。
Then let’s not turn “we don’t know” into “nothing happened.” Customers can hear the difference, especially when they’re the ones left wondering whether their information is exposed.
那我们就别把“我们不知道”说成“什么都没发生”。客户听得出其中的差别,尤其是当他们只能忐忑地猜测自己的信息是否已经泄露时。
I’m not proposing silence. I’m proposing a notice that states the access occurred, says what categories of information may be involved, and makes clear that we’re still verifying the scope.
我不是主张保持沉默。我建议发布一份通知,说明确实发生了未授权访问,列出可能涉及的信息类别,并明确表示我们仍在核实影响范围。
That’s defensible, provided we don’t imply that every customer’s data was affected. We also need to explain what we’re doing now and when people can expect another update.
只要我们不暗示每位客户的数据都受到了影响,这样的表述就站得住脚。我们还需要说明目前采取了哪些措施,以及客户何时能收到下一次更新。
And avoid the soothing phrases that soothe no one—“no evidence of misuse,” for instance, can sound like “we checked thoroughly” when we haven’t finished checking.
还要避免那些根本安抚不了人的套话——比如“没有发现滥用证据”,听起来可能像是“我们已经彻底查过了”,但实际上调查还没结束。
Good point. We can say, “We have not confirmed whether information was taken or misused, and our investigation is ongoing.” It’s plain, if not exactly comforting.
说得好。我们可以这样写:“我们尚未确认信息是否被获取或滥用,调查仍在进行中。”这话够直白,虽然谈不上让人安心。
We should also give customers practical steps without overstating their risk. If passwords may be involved, we can recommend changing them and using unique credentials, while clarifying that this is precautionary.
我们也应该给客户提供实际可行的建议,但不要夸大他们面临的风险。如果密码可能涉及其中,我们可以建议他们更改密码并使用独立密码,同时说明这属于预防措施。
Let’s be careful with “may be involved.” Do we have a basis for that, or are we adding password advice because it sounds reassuring? A precaution still needs a factual reason.
“可能涉及”这几个字得谨慎使用。我们有依据这么说吗?还是只是觉得建议改密码听起来比较让人安心?即使是预防措施,也得有事实依据。
The system contained encrypted password data, but we’re still assessing whether it was accessible in usable form. We can state that distinction and avoid claiming the passwords were compromised.
该系统存有经过加密的密码数据,但我们仍在评估这些数据是否能以可用形式被访问。我们可以说明这一区别,避免声称密码已经泄露。
Then that’s our line: candid about the unauthorized access, precise about what we know, explicit about what we don’t, and specific about when we’ll update people—even if some answers remain unavailable.
那我们的表述原则就定为:坦诚说明发生了未授权访问,准确交代已知情况,明确指出尚不清楚的部分,并具体说明何时更新信息——即使届时仍有些问题无法回答。
That’s more credible than a polished promise of certainty. People may not like uncertainty, but they’re less likely to trust us if we pretend it isn’t there.
这比包装得很漂亮、却承诺一切都已确定的说法更可信。人们或许不喜欢不确定性,但如果我们假装它不存在,他们就更难信任我们。
词汇8
- responsibly tell customers负责任地告知客户
To share information with customers in a careful and ethical way. In this context, it means being honest without claiming more than the team knows.
以谨慎、合乎道德的方式向客户分享信息。在这里,这意味着如实说明情况,不夸大团队掌握的信息。
- the investigation is still active调查仍在进行中
The investigation is ongoing and has not yet reached a conclusion. This phrase signals that the facts may still change as more information is gathered.
调查还在继续,尚未得出结论。这种说法表明,随着收集到更多信息,事实仍可能发生变化。
- distinguish what’s confirmed from what remains under investigation区分已确认的事实和仍在调查的事项
To make clear which facts are established and which are still uncertain. This helps people understand the limits of what you can say.
明确哪些事实已经得到证实,哪些仍不确定。这样能让人们了解目前能够说明的范围。
- under investigation正在调查中
Being examined or checked to find out what happened. Use this phrase when the available facts are not yet conclusive.
正在接受调查或核查,以查明发生了什么。如果现有事实还不足以下定论,就可以用这个说法。
- scope范围
The extent or range of something. Here, it means how many customers or records may have been affected.
指某件事涉及的程度或范围。在这里,指可能受到影响的客户或记录有多少。
- precautionary预防性的
Done to reduce a possible risk, even when harm has not been confirmed. The word helps explain that advice is sensible but does not prove that a customer’s data was compromised.
为了降低潜在风险而采取的,即使尚未确认已经造成损害。这个词可以说明,相关建议是合理的预防措施,但并不能证明客户的数据已经遭到泄露。
- factual reason事实依据
A reason supported by evidence or known facts. In this dialogue, it means advice should be based on a real risk, not included merely to sound reassuring.
有证据或已知事实支持的理由。在这段对话中,它表示建议应当基于真实风险,而不是为了听起来让人安心才提出。
- candid about坦诚说明
Open and honest about something, including its difficult or uncertain parts. It is useful when describing a transparent approach to communication.
公开、诚实地说明某件事,包括其中棘手或尚不确定的部分。描述透明的沟通方式时,这个表达很有用。
重点句子6
- 1
The investigation is still active, but silence has its own cost—and may look like we’re waiting for certainty we may never get.
调查仍在进行中,但保持沉默也有代价——而且可能让人觉得我们在等待一个也许永远无法得到的确切答案。
This sentence weighs the risks of speaking too soon against the risks of saying nothing. Reuse the structure “X has its own cost” to explain why inaction may also cause harm.
这句话权衡了过早发声和什么都不说各自带来的风险。你可以套用 “X has its own cost” 来说明不采取行动也可能造成伤害。
- 2
We should distinguish what’s confirmed from what remains under investigation.
我们应该区分已确认的事实和仍在调查的事项。
This is a concise way to recommend separating established facts from unresolved questions. Use it when communicating about an ongoing investigation or any uncertain situation.
这是建议把已证实的事实与尚未解决的问题分开说明的一种简洁表达。沟通正在进行的调查或任何不确定的情况时,都可以使用。
- 3
Customers can hear the difference, especially when they’re the ones left wondering whether their information is exposed.
客户听得出其中的差别,尤其是当他们只能忐忑地猜测自己的信息是否已经泄露时。
This sentence emphasizes how uncertainty affects the people waiting for answers. Reuse “left wondering whether…” to describe the impact of leaving someone without clear information.
这句话强调了不确定性会如何影响等待答复的人。你可以用 “left wondering whether…” 来描述因为没有得到明确信息而让人一直心存疑问的情况。
- 4
We can say, “We have not confirmed whether information was taken or misused, and our investigation is ongoing.”
我们可以这样说:“我们尚未确认信息是否被获取或滥用,调查仍在进行中。”
This gives a measured way to acknowledge uncertainty without suggesting that nothing happened. The structure “We have not confirmed whether…” is useful when evidence is incomplete.
这种说法以审慎的方式承认情况尚不确定,同时避免暗示什么都没发生。证据不完整时,可以使用 “We have not confirmed whether…” 这个句式。
- 5
A precaution still needs a factual reason.
采取预防措施也得有事实依据。
This short statement warns that advice should be supported by evidence, even when it is offered as a safeguard. Use it to question whether a recommendation is justified.
这句简短的话提醒我们,即使建议是为了防范风险,也应该有证据支持。你可以用它来质疑某项建议是否合理。
- 6
People may not like uncertainty, but they’re less likely to trust us if we pretend it isn’t there.
人们或许不喜欢不确定性,但如果我们假装它不存在,他们就更难信任我们。
This sentence explains why acknowledging uncertainty can build trust. Reuse the contrast “People may not like X, but…” to argue for a more honest or realistic approach.
这句话说明,承认不确定性有助于建立信任。你可以套用 “People may not like X, but…” 来主张采取更诚实、更现实的做法。